List of Heresies

General discussions about Christianity including salvation, heaven and hell, Christian history and so on.
Mallz
Advanced Senior Member
Posts: 809
Joined: Sun Mar 17, 2013 8:34 am
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male

Re: List of Heresies

Post by Mallz »

they have been placed there because of Gods foreknowledge. Outside of salvation by predestination
Hmm, I believe this but I'm not a Calvanist.
From my understanding it works like this:
YHWH is omniscient. That being said, He knows who will come to Him and will not before they are born. Knowing His other attributes (such as Justice, for one) and that He wishes all to come to Him (omnibenevolent, my favorite), we can know that He placed everyone who would exist in time and space for the purpose of maximizing the amount who will come to Him. Puts us in the best positions in our life for our personalities and who will we be. The Earth is the womb for the Sons of God to be born into, refined through and then glorified from.
In fact, this shows His love as He places everyone in the best chance to come to Him. And those that won't are placed for those that will or to further move along the times to fulfill His plans.
But that doesn't negate free will. Just because He knows what you are going to have for dinner tonight, doesn't mean you had no decision in it.
User avatar
melanie
Esteemed Senior Member
Posts: 1417
Joined: Sat May 10, 2014 3:18 am
Christian: Yes
Sex: Female

Re: List of Heresies

Post by melanie »

Mallz wrote:
they have been placed there because of Gods foreknowledge. Outside of salvation by predestination
Hmm, I believe this but I'm not an Calvanist.
From my understanding it works like this:
YHWH is omniscient. That being said, He knows who will come to Him and will not before they are born. Knowing His other attributes (such as Justice, for one) and that He wishes all to come to Him, we can know that He placed everyone who would exist in time and space for the purpose of maximizing the amount who will come to Him. Puts us in the best positions in our life for our personalities and who will we be. The Earth is the womb for the Sons of God to be born into, refined through and then glorified from.
In fact, this shows His love as He places everyone in the best chance to come to Him. And those that won't are placed for those that will or to further move along the times to fulfill His plans.
But that doesn't negate free will. Just because He knows what you are going to have for dinner tonight, doesn't mean you had no decision in it.
So only put put beef and chicken on the menu but expect you to choose lamb?
Mallz
Advanced Senior Member
Posts: 809
Joined: Sun Mar 17, 2013 8:34 am
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male

Re: List of Heresies

Post by Mallz »

More like beef and chicken is on the menu but he knows your going to be like 'forget that, I'm gettin meself and ma fam lamb!'
User avatar
melanie
Esteemed Senior Member
Posts: 1417
Joined: Sat May 10, 2014 3:18 am
Christian: Yes
Sex: Female

Re: List of Heresies

Post by melanie »

melanie wrote:
Mallz wrote:
they have been placed there because of Gods foreknowledge. Outside of salvation by predestination
Hmm, I believe this but I'm not an Calvanist.
From my understanding it works like this:
YHWH is omniscient. That being said, He knows who will come to Him and will not before they are born. Knowing His other attributes (such as Justice, for one) and that He wishes all to come to Him, we can know that He placed everyone who would exist in time and space for the purpose of maximizing the amount who will come to Him. Puts us in the best positions in our life for our personalities and who will we be. The Earth is the womb for the Sons of God to be born into, refined through and then glorified from.
In fact, this shows His love as He places everyone in the best chance to come to Him. And those that won't are placed for those that will or to further move along the times to fulfill His plans.
But that doesn't negate free will. Just because He knows what you are going to have for dinner tonight, doesn't mean you had no decision in it.
So only put put beef and chicken on the menu but expect you to choose lamb?
Or perhaps the better analogy would be be only put beef and chicken on the menu when lamb is the much better choice but you didn't even know it.
Mallz
Advanced Senior Member
Posts: 809
Joined: Sun Mar 17, 2013 8:34 am
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male

Re: List of Heresies

Post by Mallz »

Then the lamb came and revealed Himself by creating a feast inviting all to partake of ^_^
User avatar
melanie
Esteemed Senior Member
Posts: 1417
Joined: Sat May 10, 2014 3:18 am
Christian: Yes
Sex: Female

Re: List of Heresies

Post by melanie »

I have some very close aboriginal friends, whose ancestors have lived here for thousands of years. White man only came here a couple hundred years ago, they were isolated, completely. No chance of the gospel being brought here up untill relatively quite recently. Too bad, God meant for it to be that way. Multiple generations didn't gave a chance because they didn't deserve it to begin with, but in the meantime here's the 'Good News'.
Great news for them. Under those conditions I wouldn't blame them for turning away.
We have to be very careful what we preach.
The harm it can cause.
Is it biblical or personal opinion?
Mallz
Advanced Senior Member
Posts: 809
Joined: Sun Mar 17, 2013 8:34 am
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male

Re: List of Heresies

Post by Mallz »

Why do you think they were damned without the gospel?

*Edit
Also..
Abraham didn't have the gospel, or the law. He isn't damned.
User avatar
melanie
Esteemed Senior Member
Posts: 1417
Joined: Sat May 10, 2014 3:18 am
Christian: Yes
Sex: Female

Re: List of Heresies

Post by melanie »

Mallz wrote:Why do you think they were damned without the gospel?

*Edit
Also..
Abraham didn't have the gospel, or the law. He isn't damned.
I don't think they are, far be it from me to make that assumption. I'll leave that up to God.
User avatar
Philip
Site Owner
Posts: 9522
Joined: Mon Dec 28, 2009 7:45 pm
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male
Creation Position: Day-Age
Location: Betwixt the Sea and the Mountains

Re: List of Heresies

Post by Philip »

Mel: Brought up again in your Calvinistic views
Er, Mel, if you are speaking of Five Point Calvinism or where God provides some salvation and deliberately denies or withholds it from all others, meaning he has predestined their decision to REJECT God/they were created INCAPABLE of desiring to know God - that is both unBiblical and I have spoken prolifically on this forum AGAINST such a view.
Mel: ...that we have discussed previously and you know I don't agree with, being that millions of people have been born with Gods foreknowledge that they will perish, based on race and/or location, era ect. God does not handicap anyone. We are all born with the same grace, love and opportunity as the next.
I would just add that ALL are capable of seeking God or of rejecting Him. And that any perceived handicap of time, place and remote distance is NO barrier for God. His only barrier is Self-imposed - that is, He will not force love on anyone determined to resist Him, to avoid Him, to not seek the God that the Creation has made His existence known to ALL. NO matter one's remoteness, they CAN seek God, and He will always respond to those who do!
Mel: I take my salvation with up most humility.
I am not exclusive.
Gods love is not exclusive.
I do not view my 'Christianity' as anything I have earned because God knows I don't deserve it. Every single person I come across despite their background, their religious persuasion, their outward appearance is just as 'unworthy' as me. But God loves us anyway. He see's past what man's eyes can see,. He see's what could be, what can be, He see's our heart, our humility.
Yes, God does love ALL. But while salvation can in no way be earned, God did tell us there is only one way to that - through faith in Christ. And that all who do not seek this will die in their sins, separated from God for an eternity. Because if they wanted to know the path to salvation, they would seek and not attempt to avoid Him, pretend He doesn't exist, settle on a false/man-made construct of who others say He is. Of course, through unfathomable grace and mercy, He HAS revealed Himself to all. But Scripture doesn't teach that mere belief in His existence will save. Nor will unobeyed knowledge of the Gospel.
Mel: God calls us to Him, in His way, in His timeframe, by His will.
The fact that I am called by His grace is a blessing that I take with a love to everyone I come across. Not as a exclusive passage into heaven but as a inclusive compassion and love to all.
SCRIPTURE teaches that there most certainly IS an exclusive path to God - through JESUS!

"And there is salvation in no one else; for there is no other name under heaven that has been given among men by which we must be saved." (Acts 4:12)

Romans 10: “The word is near you; it is in your mouth and in your heart,”[d] that is, the message concerning faith that we proclaim: 9 IF you declare with your mouth, “Jesus is Lord,” and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. 10 For it is with your heart that you believe and are justified, and it is with your mouth that you profess your faith and are saved. 11 As Scripture says, “Anyone who believes in him will never be put to shame.”[e] 12 For there is no difference between Jew and Gentile—the same Lord is Lord of all and richly blesses ALLwho call on him, 13 for, “Everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved.”[f]

So, the above tells the conditions of one's heart, mind and ACTIONS God requires for salvation. But then it makes sense that one would reasonably ask how the above is possible if one does not have the Gospel to do so. And so, same Romans 10 sequence (below) continues with that answer:

14 How, then, can they call on the one they have not believed in? And how can they believe in the one of whom they have not heard? And how can they hear without someone preaching to them? 15 And how can anyone preach unless they are sent? As it is written: “How beautiful are the feet of those who bring good news!”

Mel, again, the above does not mean that the Gospel is out of reach to ANYONE - as IF they so desire to seek and know God, then He WILL reveal Himself, somehow, miraculously, through a missionary - who knows how He might do so. Missionaries can tell you all kinds of amazing, miraculous stories. I would tend to say that those that God does not miraculously reach or doesn't provide the Gospel, it's because God knows it will not profit one who will only further reject this much fuller and crucial revealing of Himself. God's plan is perfectly positioned to save ALL who want to know Him, ALL those Who are willing, ALL those who call upon His Name. And you don't have to know the details about Him to call upon Him - that's very key to understand.
Mel: The light and love of Christ is not exclusive.
No, but it is applied conditionally upon acceptance and love of Him. And so THIS is why the Great Commission is considered so urgent - and so NECESSARY! Were countless missionary lives needlessly sacrificed around the world, when they COULD have merely stayed home because God saves without people hearing the Gospel? One can believe anything they want, but the Gospel teaches that the Gospel must first be heard and accepted before one is saved.

Again, consider the Roman Centurion Cornelius, in Acts 10. Scripture tells us that "he and all his family were devout and God-fearing; he gave generously to those in need and prayed to God regularly," HOWEVER, he was not YET saved in the eyes of the Lord. But God honored Cornelius sincere SEEKING and desire to know God, as He sent an angel who told Cornelius, “Your prayers and gifts to the poor have come up as a memorial offering before God. 5 Now send men to Joppa to bring back a man named Simon who is called Peter." Peter didn't even know a gentile COULD be saved, excepting that God showed him he "should not call anyone impure or unclean." Peter wasn't even totally sure why he was summoned by Cornelius: "May I ask why you sent for me?” Very key, Cornelius and his household were not YET saved, UNTIL Peter explains about Jesus and how God "commanded us to preach to the people and to testify that he is the one whom God appointed as judge of the living and the dead. All the prophets testify about him that everyone who believes in him receives forgiveness of sins through his name.” And so, only SUBSEQUENT to hearing and believing Peter's presentation of the Gospel did "the Holy Spirit came on all who heard the message."

We have absolutely NO references in the New Testament that anyone can be saved without first hearing and then embracing the Gospel. Period! But our faulty human reasoning deduces that this means God has handicapped people without the Gospel from being able to seek and know Him - which is totally false. But it's also completely unScriptural to believe that God saves without one first hearing and accepting the Gospel. Does He not perhaps reach many with the Gospel message, yet without sending a human being with it? That would not surprise me a bit! We just get in trouble when we go beyond what Scripture actually teaches - which is what those insisting that people in remote areas without the Gospel are likely to be saved anyway. As, IF that were true, the missionaries could simply stay home.
User avatar
Philip
Site Owner
Posts: 9522
Joined: Mon Dec 28, 2009 7:45 pm
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male
Creation Position: Day-Age
Location: Betwixt the Sea and the Mountains

Re: List of Heresies

Post by Philip »

Maltz: Why do you think they were damned without the gospel?

*Edit
Also..
Abraham didn't have the gospel, or the law. He isn't damned.
The Bible shows that God progressively revealed Who and what He is. Those believing in the one true God (pre-Christ) did not yet know about the Son/Jesus part of God's trinity. The requirement for this belief only came later, belief in the Resurrection was only possible after it had occurred - and thus it's requirement as well. Abraham had faith in God - in Whom the Father, Son and Holy Spirit ALL triunally exist. Just because Abraham hadn't been made to understand more fully Who God actually is, doesn't mean that He didn't have faith in the true God in which they all exist. So, people still had to have faith in the true God, pre-Christ, and the requirement for belief in the further Revelation of God, in Jesus' birth, ministry, death and Resurrection, only came later. Same faith, same God, subsequent and more fully understood revelation and requirement per. This is also why mere belief in a god that doesn't include faith in Christ and His Resurrection is a lack of faith in the TRUE God and would also be a rejection of Who Jesus actually is.
User avatar
RickD
Make me a Sammich Member
Posts: 22063
Joined: Thu Jan 14, 2010 7:59 am
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male
Creation Position: Day-Age
Location: Kitchen

Re: List of Heresies

Post by RickD »

melanie wrote:
RickD wrote:Philip has Calvinistic views?

Mel,

I definitely think you misread him somewhere, if you think that.
Rick, in the past Philip and I have had discussion in several threads over the predestination of those born in time and location and he has made it clear that he believes that they have been placed there because of Gods foreknowledge. Outside of salvation by predestination.
He alluded to it, in this thread.
He may be right, I doubt it but that is his view.
Foreknowledge certainly isn't the same as a Calvinistic type of predestination.

Foreknowledge speaks of omniscience. Just because God knows what we will choose, that doesn't mean He makes us choose.

The bible seems pretty clear to me, that anyone who seeks God will find Him. That's a promise from God.
So, an aborigine who seeks God, will find Him. However God wants to do it.
John 5:24
24 “Truly, truly, I say to you, he who hears My word, and believes Him who sent Me, has eternal life, and does not come into judgment, but has passed out of death into life.


“A nation of sheep will beget a government of wolves.”
-Edward R Murrow




St. Richard the Sarcastic--The Patron Saint of Irony
User avatar
B. W.
Ultimate Member
Posts: 8355
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2005 8:17 am
Christian: Yes
Location: Colorado

Re: List of Heresies

Post by B. W. »

RickD wrote:
melanie wrote:
RickD wrote:Philip has Calvinistic views?

Mel,

I definitely think you misread him somewhere, if you think that.
Rick, in the past Philip and I have had discussion in several threads over the predestination of those born in time and location and he has made it clear that he believes that they have been placed there because of Gods foreknowledge. Outside of salvation by predestination.
He alluded to it, in this thread.
He may be right, I doubt it but that is his view.
Foreknowledge certainly isn't the same as a Calvinistic type of predestination.

Foreknowledge speaks of omniscience. Just because God knows what we will choose, that doesn't mean He makes us choose.

The bible seems pretty clear to me, that anyone who seeks God will find Him. That's a promise from God.
So, an aborigine who seeks God, will find Him. However God wants to do it.
Both Hosea and Habakkuk reveal the principle Rick pointed out...

They have set up kings, but not by Me; They have appointed, Hosea 8:4 NASB

"For behold, I am raising up the Chaldeans, that fierce and impetuous people Who march throughout the earth To seize dwelling places which are not theirs. They are dreaded and feared; Their justice and authority originate with themselves, Hab 1:6,7 NASB

Habakkuk 1:6,7 stresses that God's omnipotence is more than capable to work through all human contingencies. Human beings do indeed, and can elect their own rulers and exercise their own authority which originates within themselves. Even in the midst of this, God can raise up any kind of country to issue forth punishment or blessings however he so chooses. God can, place people in power to govern as well. He can move the hearts of people while at the same time letting them move in their own devises. There is none like God. These verses also shows God is not slave to free will either because being all powerful is just that - all powerfully able to work through anything.
-
-
-
Science is man's invention - creation is God's
(by B. W. Melvin)

Old Polish Proverb:
Not my Circus....not my monkeys
User avatar
Philip
Site Owner
Posts: 9522
Joined: Mon Dec 28, 2009 7:45 pm
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male
Creation Position: Day-Age
Location: Betwixt the Sea and the Mountains

Re: List of Heresies

Post by Philip »

Mel: he (Philip) has made it clear that he believes that they have been placed there because of Gods foreknowledge.
Yes, per God's foreknowledge AND His eternal purposes.

It is impossible for God to do anything He doesn't have COMPLETE foreknowledge of. As Rick stated, God's foreknowledge is not the same as predestining ONE's CHOICE AS TO SALVATION (which Calvinists believe). There is a very big difference between God having ALWAYS fully KNOWN all future choices of all people, as to whether or not they would one day reject Him, as in pre-making/pre-deciding their choice FOR them - whether to reject Christ or embrace Him (there is NO choice in salvation as Five Point Calvinists wrongly believe). There is also a very big difference between God supposedly making one's salvation choice for people and in His having made a pre-creation decision that ALL people who will love and be willing to follow Him/have faith in Christ will be the ones who He will save (He's chosen a special destination for those OBEDIENT to Him AS HE REVEALS HIMSELF to them - all the way to salvation). So, God pre-set the conditions for those who will be saved before anyone ever existed. HOWEVER, salvation is not merely or ONLY based upon His foreknowledge of our future choices, but FIRST of HIS decision to save those who would obey/have a heart for Him, and to also (without any human ability or choice involved), it was His decision to reach to us and open our eyes FIRST, through His Word, by wooing us, and revealing Himself to us. We could not be saved or even have a choice if not for God FIRST doing these things (and, of course, not without Jesus' sacrifice at Calvary). Actually, and as to some supposed sequence of WHICH God did first - foreknow our future choices or decide to save those who would one day obey - these are all simultaneous with God, as He sees ALL of history on one page, all at once, knows ALL of His choices regarding such things - and these choices He's ALWAYS known - as He's simply ALL-knowing.

And while God has revealed to ALL that He exists, He further personally reveals and gives the ability to believe (ANYONE can have such an ability IF they desire to/are so WILLING) to those He also intimately foreknows will, one day, accept and be drawn to Him - although no one HAS to receive Him (ALL can either accept or reject). This is why God foreknew that, for many, the Gospel would not profit them, as He has always foreknown the hearts and attitudes of those determined to resist Him at all cost. For many who have already rejected or He foreknows, one day, WILL reject what He has "clearly" and ALREADY shown EVERYONE (the basics: that He exists, provides for them, has created an amazing world and universe), He does not further provide them the Gospel, as He undoubtedly intimately knows they will only reject that further revelation about Himself. But WE cannot know who these people are - and thus, the "Great Commission," driven and directed by God's Holy Spirit (notice that it's a CO-mission!).

Hope that clarifies some important nuances to this issue.
Mallz
Advanced Senior Member
Posts: 809
Joined: Sun Mar 17, 2013 8:34 am
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male

Re: List of Heresies

Post by Mallz »

Phillip,
Are you saying that after Christ died, no one can be saved apart from knowing about the man God Jesus Christ?
If yes, I'm having a hard time reasoning that to be true. I can see it working, but in a pretty complicated fashion that would assume a lot...
So, what about the mentally ill, children who never knew Him, etc.? No matter what, they never knew the gospel or got to know Jesus to accept him.
What about Romans 4?

I know He works in progressive revelation. However, He is the same today as yesterday and tomorrow. I see it being more than just a rule but the spirit which the rule comes from.
Also, I don't think you can assume that about Abraham or people pre Jesus. You think Abraham or Moses or the prophets close to Him, or the man David who was man after His heart didn't know God? That He was more than one person hood?
Do you know much about the Kabbalah? Or ancient Hebrew studies? The concept of the trinity was known pre-Christ..

I know people get visions from Christ and come to Him that way. So maybe those without the gospel get more special revelations such as this.
However, It still doesn't sit right with me that there's a rule:
Post Jesus Christs revelations, no one can be saved that doesn't know Him. Yes that is true, but those who never had the chance? I think there's more to it than just 'God placed them there with His foreknowledge' .
Also, people have known Him without the gospel.
Also, it's the Holy Spirit that brings people to Him, not us. We are just tools that need to be ready to be used.

I'd be really interested in discussing this further with you, and anyone who wants to jump in. I need this fleshed out at least for myself...
User avatar
Philip
Site Owner
Posts: 9522
Joined: Mon Dec 28, 2009 7:45 pm
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male
Creation Position: Day-Age
Location: Betwixt the Sea and the Mountains

Re: List of Heresies

Post by Philip »

Mallz: Phillip, Are you saying that after Christ died, no one can be saved apart from knowing about the man God Jesus Christ?
That is the ONLY way we see for salvation in the New Testament, yes. However, we don't know how God might miraculously make some aware of the Gospel.
Mallz: If yes, I'm having a hard time reasoning that to be true. I can see it working, but in a pretty complicated fashion that would assume a lot... So, what about the mentally ill, children who never knew Him, etc.? No matter what, they never knew the gospel or got to know Jesus to accept him.
God does not require from anyone something they CANNOT do: A child cannot clearly understand his sin/guilt, his responsibility. Neither can those mentally incapable. I believe there is good reason to believe that children that die are instantly in the presence of the Lord.
Mallz: What about Romans 4?
I don't see Romans 4 changing that the God Abraham had faith in was the one true God - of which Jesus is a part.
Mallz: Also, I don't think you can assume that about Abraham or people pre Jesus. You think Abraham or Moses or the prophets close to Him, or the man David who was man after His heart didn't know God? Those OT saints DID know God, but those after Christ (and now, obviously those OT saints TODAY do) have had the advantage of knowing more fully Who God is. Also, believers post-Christ have God's Holy Spirit in a way that believers pre-Christ did not.

Mallz: That He was more than one person hood?
No, I don't believe those pre-Christ understood this. If any did, we don't know for sure. The three that appeared outside of Abraham's tent in Genesis 18 - I don't know... Certainly, there was no clear understanding of the Trinity, pre-Jesus. Was there thirst and prophecied expectation for a Messiah? Of course.
Mallz: Do you know much about the Kabbalah? Or ancient Hebrew studies? The concept of the trinity was known pre-Christ.
Whatever the case, all tenuous at best, mostly very obscure, the Trinitarian nature of God was clearly not understood.
Mallz: I know people get visions from Christ and come to Him that way. So maybe those without the gospel get more special revelations such as this.

However, It still doesn't sit right with me that there's a rule: Post Jesus Christs revelations, no one can be saved that doesn't know Him. Yes that is true, but those who never had the chance? I think there's more to it than just 'God placed them there with His foreknowledge' .
The CHANCE people have is that ALL CAN sincerely seek and communicate with God anytime they so desire to - and He will honor their seeking. If receptive and desirous, God will do all necessary for those so willing so that they have the Gospel and all needed to receive it. Whether He informs them personally (as He did Paul on the road to Damascus, in a vision (like that sent Cornelius), or by sending a missionary.
Mallz: Also, people have known Him without the gospel.
But not in the NT/post-Christ. Not ONE person comes to salvation in the NT without first hearing the Gospel.
Mallz: Also, it's the Holy Spirit that brings people to Him, not us. We are just tools that need to be ready to be used.
I totally agree with that. Now, do you think God is limited in reaching and wooing ANYONE that He foreknows will be receptive to progressively more detailed revelations about Himself?

I think the big issues are: 1) People assume that God's placement of people is totally random and not based upon His plan of salvation; 2) They deny but nonetheless pragmatically think that remote geography and place in time handicaps people from knowing the Lord - or that such variables handicap GOD's ability to reach them; 3) People assume that in order to reject God, they must first know about both Jesus and the Gospel - but Romans totally refutes that; 4) People worry that if EVERYONE must first hear and then embrace the Gospel before they can be saved that this means that A) God is not fair and B) He didn't mean to save them anyway. Look at our own Western society - Gospel freely and prolifically saturates the culture - and yet how few is the number of people who become Christians, in comparison to the total population. People tend to not want anything to do with the things and knowledge of God - which is what Paul said in Romans was true from the beginning.

Mallz, I believe that the God who has created on a scale so vast and detailed - down to the molecular level and smaller - that He's left absolutely NOTHING to chance. And so that HOW, WHERE and WHEN He has placed people in time, place and culture is in NO way random or irrespective of the fact that His placements, those He sends them, and ALL of the parameters that He completely controls - ALL of these things were designed to work together to save absolutely EVERY single person who God knows will not permanently resist or avoid Him if He reveals Himself to them. The salvation of those remote is NOT limited by any parameter that man sees as a limitation. It's also not limited by man's obvious limitations - as God is control of every person and every parameter - and He uses Believers as His perfect wisdom and knowledge of all things work together to accomplish. We must consider that some (even MOST) were placed remote from the Gospel (in place or/and time) because God has always foreknown that their proximity to the Gospel would not be of value to them - as He knows such people will only permanently resist ALL of His initiatives and enlightenment. Whereas WE cannot know who will respond and who will only permanently and stubbornly resist God.

All I'm saying is that: 1) we have NO NT evidence to the contrary that hearing the Gospel and then embracing it isn't crucial to one's salvation, and 2) We should never assume more than Scripture actually teaches. Paul even rhetorically asks how will people be saved without someone bringing them the Gospel. Is this revealing mere ignorance of the answer? What? Is the Great Commission urgent or not? If so, WHY so? If people without the Gospel are saved anyway - why do missions at all? In fact, would not doing missions give people a responsibility and knowledge of God's requirement of faith that might doom those who nonetheless reject it? If so, wouldn't it be more eternally safe to keep such people in the dark about the Gospel - as their possible rejection of it would certainly doom them?
Post Reply