God said to me..

[Nessa]

what do you guys think of prophesy outside of the bible and people saying that God told them something.....

to quote peeta.."real or not real"?

[Byblos]

what do you guys think of prophesy outside of the bible and people saying that God told them something.....

to quote peeta.."real or not real"?

Private revelations are just that, private.

[melanie]

what do you guys think of prophesy outside of the bible and people saying that God told them something.....

to quote peeta.."real or not real"?

I am sceptical.
History is littered with crackpots who claim all kinds of things. Cults are started that way.
We are understandably very wary of people that claim that God has spoken to them.....
But God does communicate with believers.
Many believe we are living in the last days, and scripture says "'In the last days, God says, I will pour out my Spirit on all people. Your sons and daughters will prophesy, your young men will see visions, your old men will dream dreams.

Personally I have had some very prolific dreams since I was a child, that have continued throughout my life. I have also had some pretty amazing experiences, where I believe God has communicated something to me. But it is personal. Not something I share. For two reasons, firstly because I think the intention was for personal growth and secondly because apart from my husband and family nobody would believe me. Which is okay. Because despite my experiences I tend to not believe others when claims are made because we are told to be wary because in those days false teachers and prophets will appear everywhere.

[melanie]

what do you guys think of prophesy outside of the bible and people saying that God told them something.....

to quote peeta.."real or not real"?

Private revelations are just that, private.

I didn't see your response before I posted but you hit the nail on the head!

[EssentialSacrifice]

Private revelation is just that, private and should be kept there unless instructed otherwise (if it's real). There are however some good examples of revelation that were intended to be brought to the public eye for reasons of faith and morals. there are many but the two I am most familiar with are Sister Agreda's of Spain "City of God" and Maria Valtorta's "Poem of the Man God".

These works have been put under an incredibly harsh microscope from religious and secular entities. Both have come out of the fire. If revelation is your game, not futuristic... "this is how it's gonna end, end times stuff" then you may be interested in their subject matter. These books are all about the revelation of God to his people about Jesus and Mary and their lives at the time they walked on the earth and the times of today and the influence they still, and forever will, have.

[theophilus]

The Bible is a complete revelation of all that we need to know to carry out God's will. No prophet will ever receive any revelation of new truth that needs to be added to it. However God often speaks to individuals and gives them instructions and information they need to carry out his will. For example, there was a prophet named Agabus.

Now in these days prophets came down from Jerusalem to Antioch. And one of them named Agabus stood up and foretold by the Spirit that there would be a great famine over all the world (this took place in the days of Claudius). So the disciples determined, every one according to his ability, to send relief to the brothers living in Judea. And they did so, sending it to the elders by the hand of Barnabas and Saul.
(Acts 11:27-30 ESV)

Because he warned of a coming famine the church at Antioch was able to send needed help to the church at Jerusalem.

[Byblos]

Private revelation is just that, private ...

You can say that again.

[EssentialSacrifice]

Can't help myself... fool that I must be...

[RickD]

Isn't private revelation...private?

[abelcainsbrother]

I think when it comes to prophesying we need to do it the way the bible tells us to do it,which we don't really do.1st Corinthians 14:27-33.
I think we need to keep in mind Joel 2:28 too.

[Kurieuo]

what do you guys think of prophesy outside of the bible and people saying that God told them something.....

I'd be lying if I said that I didn't believe God hasn't spoken to me in a more direct manner.
However, they were personal private messages and revelations.

[Nessa]

so are some of you saying that if God tells you a private revelation that is ok but making it public isnt? what if a group of people are standing around you praying for you and then suddenly one person gives you a personal revelation from God?

[Kurieuo]

so are some of you saying that if God tells you a private revelation that is ok but making it public isnt? what if a group of people are standing around you praying for you and then suddenly one person gives you a personal revelation from God?

I try to avoid those situations.

If it was just me, I'd tell them to stop if I'm being upfront.
No one has a right to speak words into my life especially those who don't know me and I know little about.
They can share what they feel though, but I'd quickly leave if they laid it on thick.

Why say it in a prayer, within a group, in front of everyone, unless you're trying to appear all spiritual?
It actually disgusts me. I've been caught within such and felt pressured to participate.
I was really peeved after, so I'd wouldn't let it happen again.
Better to pack up and leave.

So right now, especially if I have a low tolerance at the time, I'd probably say "sorry, I'm leaving now" and walk away.
Why should I care? I'm obviously not a part of their group or like-minded. Who knows, there might be others who then take their own cue.

There's no reason for it is there? I have Scripture. And God gave me a brain to love him with.
If I can't determine their fruit or who they are, then there's no reason to accept anything they tell me.