A question for atheists

[Nessa]

Frank Turek asks atheists this following question:

"If you knew that Christianity was true, would you become a christian"

So for those of you who are atheists - what would your reply be?

[Kenny]

Frank Turek asks atheists this following question:

"If you knew that Christianity was true, would you become a christian"

So for those of you who are atheists - what would your reply be?

Of course! If you knew theism was false, would'nt you become Atheist?

Ken

[edwardmurphy]

If Pascal's Wager became Pascal's Guarantee then I guess a lot to think about, since my other option would be to have my soul roasted in hellfire for all eternity. It would be an extremely resentful conversion if it happened. If god existed he'd have a lot of explaining to do.

This is an interesting read.

[Mallz]

If you knew theism was false, would'nt you become Atheist?

Of course.

[EssentialSacrifice]

If you knew theism was false, would'nt you become Atheist?

Unnecessary, if, acknowledging there is no theism, why would there even be atheism ? There is no light if everywhere, there is darkness.

[RickD]

If you knew theism was false, would'nt you become Atheist?

Unnecessary, if, acknowledging there is no theism, why would there even be atheism ? There is no light if everywhere, there is darkness.

[1over137]

Frank Turek asks atheists this following question:

"If you knew that Christianity was true, would you become a christian"

So for those of you who are atheists - what would your reply be?

Some years ago I would reply to you: yes.

[Kenny]

If you knew theism was false, would'nt you become Atheist?

Unnecessary, if, acknowledging there is no theism, why would there even be atheism ? There is no light if everywhere, there is darkness.

My scenario was not about "no theism" it was about if you knew theism was false.

Ken

[RickD]

If you knew theism was false, would'nt you become Atheist?

Unnecessary, if, acknowledging there is no theism, why would there even be atheism ? There is no light if everywhere, there is darkness.

My scenario was not about "no theism" it was about if you knew theism was false.

Ken

Here we go again...

Kenny,

You do realize if theism is false, that's the same as saying theism doesn't exist, don't you?

[edwardmurphy]

If you knew theism was false, would'nt you become Atheist?

Unnecessary, if, acknowledging there is no theism, why would there even be atheism ? There is no light if everywhere, there is darkness.

My scenario was not about "no theism" it was about if you knew theism was false.

Ken

Here we go again...

Kenny,

You do realize if theism is false, that's the same as saying theism doesn't exist, don't you?

Sure, in a world where everyone behaved rationally. Here on Earth there are still people who think Elvis is alive and the moon landing was faked. Incontrovertible evidence that god doesn't exist and never has would definitely diminish Christianity, but it wouldn't kill it entirely. Thus there would still be theists, thus there would still be atheists...

[Nessa]

Frank Turek asks atheists this following question:

"If you knew that Christianity was true, would you become a christian"

So for those of you who are atheists - what would your reply be?

Of course! If you knew theism was false, would'nt you become Atheist?

Ken

The answer to the question is suppose to help reveal what issue the atheist has with christianity e.g moral or intellectual etc

[Nessa]

Dawkins says that if he met God after he died and knew he was then true....he would say...

"Evidence, God! Where was the evidence?!"

I dont believe it is a mere matter of evidence for him.
He is disgusted and insulted at very thought of the Christian God.
His pride and trust in his own intellect won't even let him see beyond himself.

[RickD]

If you knew theism was false, would'nt you become Atheist?

Unnecessary, if, acknowledging there is no theism, why would there even be atheism ? There is no light if everywhere, there is darkness.

My scenario was not about "no theism" it was about if you knew theism was false.

Ken

Here we go again...

Kenny,

You do realize if theism is false, that's the same as saying theism doesn't exist, don't you?

Sure, in a world where everyone behaved rationally. Here on Earth there are still people who think Elvis is alive and the moon landing was faked. Incontrovertible evidence that god doesn't exist and never has would definitely diminish Christianity, but it wouldn't kill it entirely. Thus there would still be theists, thus there would still be atheists...

Wait...what? Elvis is still alive...right?

[Kenny]

If you knew theism was false, would'nt you become Atheist?

Unnecessary, if, acknowledging there is no theism, why would there even be atheism ? There is no light if everywhere, there is darkness.

My scenario was not about "no theism" it was about if you knew theism was false.

Ken

Here we go again...

Kenny,

You do realize if theism is false, that's the same as saying theism doesn't exist, don't you?

No! As long as there are people who believe God exists, there will be theist.

Ken

[Kenny]

Frank Turek asks atheists this following question:

"If you knew that Christianity was true, would you become a christian"

So for those of you who are atheists - what would your reply be?

Of course! If you knew theism was false, would'nt you become Atheist?

Ken

The answer to the question is suppose to help reveal what issue the atheist has with christianity e.g moral or intellectual etc

It does a very poor job of it

Ken