B. W. wrote:Mr. Fortigurn, the reason that it appears to you that I am not reading your post is that I am not answering you the way you want. If you read my post again, you'll discover that I do answer all your questions but not in a manner you are familiar with.
No, the reason is that you're not answering my questions. You don't read my posts, you use terms you don't understand, you appear to cut and paste other people's work without acknowledgement, you don't reply to my arguments, and you repeat yourself in multiple posts without acknowledging my replies.
In the first page post of this thread you asked for Christians to give you specific scriptures that prove the doctrine of the Trinity and scripture evidence for it. It is there, you erred.
What I asked for - very specifically - was all the passages which define God as three persons in one being. I received a lot of verses (to which I replied), but it was generally acknowledged that there is
no passage in the Bible which says that God is three persons in one being.
First and foremost, what is doctrine? Doctrine means something taught; principles of a religion, political party, individual, etc; Tenet or tenets of a belief, etc.
Yes, I believe we can agree on that.
The Doctrine of the Trinity is based on principles found in scripture.
We've been here before (several pages ago). In other words, there are no passages which formally define and declare the doctrine. Yes, we knew that pages ago.
There is evidence for it within the scriptures. You want facts from the bible, don't you?
That's what I'm looking for, yes.
You assume Christians cannot produce any.
No I don't assume it, I know it. It has been acknowledged here that the doctrine of the trinity is derived from Scripture, not revealed in Scripture.
Thus you demand and demand proof of this Doctrine. Many have given you the proof which most of it comes from the same scriptures you use to refute this doctrine.
Many have given me passages which say absolutely zero about God being three persons in one being, a few passages which have been badly translated, and at least one 'passage' which doesn't even belong in the Bible.
Forgive me for not being convinced by such a performance.
What you are doing reminds me of the paradigm of logical fallacy. What is that? The paradigm of logical fallacy is clearly exemplified by this story. A great college English professor stands before his class and ask, “Does anyone know what a paradigm is?” and one of his students reply, “It is about Twenty Cents.”
In other words, one hears what they want too and deduces by logic what they perceive as truth based on many varied factors which produce a fallacy of reason, worldview, outlook, doctrine, belief, and etc.
You asked for specific scriptures that prove the doctrine of the Trinity, therefore I will give them to you. However, we will do so according to a few rules. Why? To thwart this paradigm from happening: these rules will clarify what is truly meant in our endeavor and that no more misunderstanding occurs between us.
This is getting weirder and weirder. Could you have someone else check your posts for coherence before you post them please? I'm really finding it difficult to read this 'stream of consciousness' style of discourse.
But before we begin, let me state clearly that the Doctrine of the Trinity stands or falls on who Jesus Christ is. To understand the Doctrine of the Trinity is to understand who Jesus is and what He did.
If you cannot grasp Jesus, you will not take hold of the Doctrine of the Trinity. Therefore, all of Christendom stands or falls on who Jesus is and what He did as well as the Doctrine of the Trinity.
The Doctrine of the Trinity is found in Christ Jesus. If you want proof of its existence, look no further than Jesus. If Jesus is not who he claims to be, then there is no Trinity. If no Trinity then there is no salvation Christians profess and you have won and can be content in this grand accomplishment. If you cannot disprove this Doctrine, what then?
If you agree, we will now begin to explore the Doctrine of the Trinity by looking at Jesus Christ and what the bible truly says on this matter a few scriptures at a time just like you asked before but this time by following a few rules to maintain order.
We will proceed in an orderly fashion, slowly, and take as long or short as it takes. I will begin with a scripture and then you will follow — one subject at a time wherever it leads. No more round robin endless debates on multiple themes. Others that read this thread please feel free to chime in and post but I ask everyone to stay within the topics theme presented within the frame under discussion.
If you read the previous pages, you'll find that I have already been through this exact same process with almost half a dozen other people.
He will begin with one scripture that sums it all up about Jesus and go from there. You asked for specific scriptures that prove the doctrine of the Trinity and scripture evidence for it. Now we will begin.
The Greek language is very specific here. It means what the English translations means. This is why I choose it.
I Timothy 3:16 “God was manifest in the flesh”
I ask, how so?
-
-
-
This was a particularly bad choice of passages on your part. I really hate to break it to you, but the Greek text
does not have 'theos' ('God'), here at all.
This reading is found in none of the earliest manuscripts, and doesn't appear in the uncials until the 8-9th centuries:
'...no uncial (in the first hand) earlier than the eighth or ninth century (Ψ) supports θεός; all ancient versions presuppose ὅς or ὅ; and no patristic writer prior to the last third of the fourth century testifies to the reading θεός.'
Bruce Metzger, 'A Textual Commentary To The Greek New Testament', page 574, 1994
If you had taken the time to do even a little research, you would have discovered this fact. You would also have discovered that most modern Bible translations recognise this:
New English Translation:
16 And we all agree, our religion contains amazing revelation: He was revealed in the flesh,
New American Bible:
16 Undeniably great is the mystery of devotion, Who was manifested in the flesh,
New Century Version:
16 Without doubt, the secret of our life of worship is great: He was shown to us in a human body,
Revised Standard Version:
16 Great indeed, we confess, is the mystery of our religion: He was manifested in the flesh,
New Revised Standard Version:
16 Without any doubt, the mystery of our religion is great: He was revealed in flesh,
American Standard Version:
16 And without controversy great is the mystery of godliness; He who was manifested in the flesh,
Contemporary English Version:
16 Here is the great mystery of our religion: Christ came as a human.
Good News Bible:
16 No one can deny how great is the secret of our religion: He appeared in human form,
Please check your facts before continuing this discussion, especially when it comes to textual criticism.