Terri Shiavo's quality of life

Discussion for Christian perspectives on ethical issues such as abortion, euthanasia, sexuality, and so forth.

Was Terri really Alive during her last days?

Yes
9
69%
No
4
31%
 
Total votes: 13

User avatar
Darwin_Rocks
Recognized Member
Posts: 80
Joined: Wed Mar 16, 2005 8:28 pm
Christian: No
Location: Australia

Terri Shiavo's quality of life

Post by Darwin_Rocks »

I read an article on the internet that really shed some light on the subject for me.

Firstly I think that idea of her ever being rehabilitated were grossly exaggerated. This is due primarily because her brain was almost totally destroyed.
A CT scan taken in 1996 revealed profound abnormalities. An EEG performed reveals that there is no electrical activity. In 2002, a CAT scan demonstrated massive atrophy. In place of normal brain tissue, almost all that is left are connective tissues and spinal fluid. Aside from a brain stem that keeps some autonomic functions going, she simply doesn't have a brain.
Im trying to understand from a christian perspective why there is such a want to keep her alive. I mean her brain was gone, the only really functions she could perform were as a result of her brain stem. The rest was all destroyed.
When your brain is gone, it's gone for good. Some describe Terri Schiavo as “brain damaged,” but this is as irresponsible as it is inaccurate. Terri Schiavo is “brain damaged” in the same way that a quadruple amputee has “arm damage.”
Why keep someone alive if they have no real awareness of their surroundings? If all their brain activity allows them to do is the basic necesities of human life. To me it seems like Terri is alive only in the sense that some of her major organs were working, her brain the thing that creates an actual quality of life was gone.

Discuss if you wish.

PS: This is my first ever poll, I'd be excited if it wasn't such a sombre topic under discussion.
User avatar
bizzt
Prestigious Senior Member
Posts: 1654
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 12:11 pm
Christian: No
Location: Calgary

Re: Terri Shiavo's quality of life

Post by bizzt »

Darwin_Rocks wrote:I read an article on the internet that really shed some light on the subject for me.

Firstly I think that idea of her ever being rehabilitated were grossly exaggerated. This is due primarily because her brain was almost totally destroyed.
A CT scan taken in 1996 revealed profound abnormalities. An EEG performed reveals that there is no electrical activity. In 2002, a CAT scan demonstrated massive atrophy. In place of normal brain tissue, almost all that is left are connective tissues and spinal fluid. Aside from a brain stem that keeps some autonomic functions going, she simply doesn't have a brain.
Im trying to understand from a christian perspective why there is such a want to keep her alive. I mean her brain was gone, the only really functions she could perform were as a result of her brain stem. The rest was all destroyed.
When your brain is gone, it's gone for good. Some describe Terri Schiavo as “brain damaged,” but this is as irresponsible as it is inaccurate. Terri Schiavo is “brain damaged” in the same way that a quadruple amputee has “arm damage.”
Why keep someone alive if they have no real awareness of their surroundings? If all their brain activity allows them to do is the basic necesities of human life. To me it seems like Terri is alive only in the sense that some of her major organs were working, her brain the thing that creates an actual quality of life was gone.

Discuss if you wish.

PS: This is my first ever poll, I'd be excited if it wasn't such a sombre topic under discussion.
Basically the main problems I had were the deprivation of Food and Water. BUT what I had a Problem the most with this case was the Way Michael Schavio acted. To tell you the truth after her death he still acts like an Idiot. Taking Terri's ashes or body to PA away from her parents and on top of that did not want to disclose the location of the Funeral.

My Two Cents
User avatar
AttentionKMartShoppers
Ultimate Member
Posts: 2163
Joined: Tue Feb 15, 2005 8:37 pm
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male
Location: Austin, Texas
Contact:

Post by AttentionKMartShoppers »

I've only got one cent, I spent the rest.

If Terri were a vegetable, then she would have been in bed, staring at the ceiling...something like the last scene in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's nest. But, she did move around and respond to people. But, if my sources are wrong, and the lights were on but nobody was really home-she was not alive. Only in a biological sense was she alive-heart pumping, breathing, etc... The driver is gone even though the car is running? I'd say kill the engine in that case....
"My actions prove that God takes care of idiots."

He occasionally stumbled over the truth, but hastily picked himself up and hurried on as if nothing had happened.
- On Stanley Baldwin

-Winston Churchill

An atheist can't find God for the same reason a criminal can't find a police officer.

You need to start asking out girls so that you can get used to the rejections.
-Anonymous
User avatar
bizzt
Prestigious Senior Member
Posts: 1654
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 12:11 pm
Christian: No
Location: Calgary

Post by bizzt »

AttentionKMartShoppers wrote:I've only got one cent, I spent the rest.

If Terri were a vegetable, then she would have been in bed, staring at the ceiling...something like the last scene in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's nest. But, she did move around and respond to people. But, if my sources are wrong, and the lights were on but nobody was really home-she was not alive. Only in a biological sense was she alive-heart pumping, breathing, etc... The driver is gone even though the car is running? I'd say kill the engine in that case....
Good Analogy... But would you let the Engine run out of Gas or just turn it off? :wink:
Dan
Valued Member
Posts: 288
Joined: Wed Mar 16, 2005 6:58 pm
Christian: No
Location: Syosset, New York

Post by Dan »

Where's the 'maybe' option? You know I've heard directly contradictory reports of schiavo's brain so I can't possibly make the decision now. When in doubt, go life. There could always be a chance.
Felgar
Esteemed Senior Member
Posts: 1143
Joined: Tue Nov 09, 2004 9:24 am
Christian: No
Location: Calgary, Canada

Post by Felgar »

Dan wrote:Where's the 'maybe' option? You know I've heard directly contradictory reports of schiavo's brain so I can't possibly make the decision now. When in doubt, go life. There could always be a chance.
I agree. We didn't really have any way to know FOR SURE that she was not able to comprehend her environment. And since there's no way to know, we have a moral obligation to preserve life as best we can. It's kind of like negotiating with terrorists, once you take the line from "absolutely not" to "well, maybe" then you're openning the door for the very things that you oppose.
User avatar
AttentionKMartShoppers
Ultimate Member
Posts: 2163
Joined: Tue Feb 15, 2005 8:37 pm
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male
Location: Austin, Texas
Contact:

Post by AttentionKMartShoppers »

I wouldn't kill the engine (metaphors....), I would let it run out of gas, because who knows, the lack of support my cause the driver to wake up...
"My actions prove that God takes care of idiots."

He occasionally stumbled over the truth, but hastily picked himself up and hurried on as if nothing had happened.
- On Stanley Baldwin

-Winston Churchill

An atheist can't find God for the same reason a criminal can't find a police officer.

You need to start asking out girls so that you can get used to the rejections.
-Anonymous
User avatar
Darwin_Rocks
Recognized Member
Posts: 80
Joined: Wed Mar 16, 2005 8:28 pm
Christian: No
Location: Australia

Post by Darwin_Rocks »

I did put a maybe option on this poll and went to submit but it didn't work. Maybe I did something wrong.

I dont think it is enough to just say 'if there is any confusion to just keep the life.' we really need to do more research into it rather than just kick back and wait for something to happen. The majority of reports I have read suggest that her brain was pretty much totally destroyed.

plus the tapes that we see of her moving around were probably heavily edited.
User avatar
AttentionKMartShoppers
Ultimate Member
Posts: 2163
Joined: Tue Feb 15, 2005 8:37 pm
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male
Location: Austin, Texas
Contact:

Post by AttentionKMartShoppers »

It's a :roll: conspiracy!
"My actions prove that God takes care of idiots."

He occasionally stumbled over the truth, but hastily picked himself up and hurried on as if nothing had happened.
- On Stanley Baldwin

-Winston Churchill

An atheist can't find God for the same reason a criminal can't find a police officer.

You need to start asking out girls so that you can get used to the rejections.
-Anonymous
Felgar
Esteemed Senior Member
Posts: 1143
Joined: Tue Nov 09, 2004 9:24 am
Christian: No
Location: Calgary, Canada

Post by Felgar »

Darwin_Rocks wrote:I dont think it is enough to just say 'if there is any confusion to just keep the life.'
Why isn't that enough? What can possibly be more valuable than a human life? What can possibly outweigh the risk of murdering an innocent person?
Dan
Valued Member
Posts: 288
Joined: Wed Mar 16, 2005 6:58 pm
Christian: No
Location: Syosset, New York

Post by Dan »

Darwin_Rocks wrote:I did put a maybe option on this poll and went to submit but it didn't work. Maybe I did something wrong.

I dont think it is enough to just say 'if there is any confusion to just keep the life.' we really need to do more research into it rather than just kick back and wait for something to happen. The majority of reports I have read suggest that her brain was pretty much totally destroyed.

plus the tapes that we see of her moving around were probably heavily edited.
Then they should've kept her alive long enough to be able to do a conclusive examination of her in first person. No one who said that she was dead actually examined her first-hand and there were no tests done prior to the decision. It was just kill and get on with it, which is... not good.
User avatar
Darwin_Rocks
Recognized Member
Posts: 80
Joined: Wed Mar 16, 2005 8:28 pm
Christian: No
Location: Australia

Post by Darwin_Rocks »

I thought a first hand analysis had been done, at least on CNN I saw a doctor reporting his findings, he claimed that she was dead.
User avatar
Mastermind
Esteemed Senior Member
Posts: 1410
Joined: Fri Nov 19, 2004 3:22 pm

Post by Mastermind »

Darwin_Rocks wrote:I thought a first hand analysis had been done, at least on CNN I saw a doctor reporting his findings, he claimed that she was dead.
Yea, she fit quite well under Hitler's definition of what "dead" means.
Are you threatening me Master Skeptic?
User avatar
Kurieuo
Honored Member
Posts: 10038
Joined: Thu Aug 05, 2004 6:25 am
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male
Creation Position: Progressive Creationist
Location: Qld, Australia

Post by Kurieuo »

Darwin_Rocks wrote:I dont think it is enough to just say 'if there is any confusion to just keep the life.'
Err... what makes killing the default position? And wouldn't it be more reasonable to assume life rather than death?

On a different note, what happened to your position of the mother's choice to keep or abort her child? The situation seems very similar to me, only in one instance you believe the mother wanting the child is enough, while in the other it isn't.

Kurieuo.
"Whoever will call on the name of the Lord will be saved." (Romans 10:13)
Anonymous

Post by Anonymous »

ermm killing here is the default position as it is a request of terri schiavo not to be kept artificially alive.

In anycase this whole thing is an issue because of the christian adherence to their dogmatic teaching that suicide is wrong.

Why is suicide even wrong?

Also to dan, they have been keeping her alive for more than 10 years, (isnt that long enough) while inumerable medical examinations has conclusively established that terry schiavo is brain dead. All the reason to pull the plug.
Post Reply