The Amazing Atheist

[Imperial]

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheAmazingA ... fbY2lJBCQk

^ Makes more sense than anything a christian could ever possibly argue.

I used to believe i was an atheist, christianity seemed like a fairy tale to me. Then when i was influenced by a few people (my family..) for some reason i felt more geared towards becoming partially Christian. This video has made clear what i was trying to understand all along.

Sorry to Gabrielman, Danny, Gman, and all the others i've had discussions with but Atheism truely makes more sense to me.

The way i see it...

Atheism = Logical with some Proof

Christianity = Highly illogical, fairy tale'ish, impossible to prove (no proof at all)

[Gabrielman]

Atheism = Logical with some Proof

Christianity = Highly illogical, fairy tale'ish, impossible to prove (no proof at all)

Excuse me? And how did you come to that conclusion? You think that it is more logical that a bunch of subatomic particles just happened to exist and be the right size and charge to form atoms that just happened to make the right chemicals to make a planet and proteins that then just happened to form cells all on their own and then just happened to come to life... yeah real logical and makes tons of sense to me. And now those atoms are talking to you and arguing that that is not the case, they have also become self aware on their own.

How does this sound, instead of putting a youtube video up why don't you explain in detail why you said that. Please, enlighten me.

[Gman]

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheAmazingA ... fbY2lJBCQk

^ Makes more sense than anything a christian could ever possibly argue.

I used to believe i was an atheist, christianity seemed like a fairy tale to me. Then when i was influenced by a few people (my family..) for some reason i felt more geared towards becoming partially Christian. This video has made clear what i was trying to understand all along.

Sorry to Gabrielman, Danny, Gman, and all the others i've had discussions with but Atheism truely makes more sense to me.

The way i see it...

Atheism = Logical with some Proof

Christianity = Highly illogical, fairy tale'ish, impossible to prove (no proof at all)

Unfortunately the way of Christ is love Mark 12:31.... Christians don't even claim to have a moral superiority Philippians 2:3.

And as far as proof is concerned, there is no scientific proof that anyone could use to "dis-prove" God.

But it really doesn't matter... Why? Because no one would believe this nor really want to understand anyway...

Just keep on fighting.. fight.. fight.. fight..

[August]

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheAmazingA ... fbY2lJBCQk

^ Makes more sense than anything a christian could ever possibly argue.

I used to believe i was an atheist, christianity seemed like a fairy tale to me. Then when i was influenced by a few people (my family..) for some reason i felt more geared towards becoming partially Christian. This video has made clear what i was trying to understand all along.

Sorry to Gabrielman, Danny, Gman, and all the others i've had discussions with but Atheism truely makes more sense to me.

The way i see it...

Atheism = Logical with some Proof

Christianity = Highly illogical, fairy tale'ish, impossible to prove (no proof at all)

The only thing amazing about that is the amount of rubbish he can fit into 5 minutes.

So while we are on the topic, please prove your statement "Atheism = Logical with some proof" to be true. Be sure to include how you arrive at the laws of logic in the first place, and also show the proof for atheism that you talk about.

Let's start with that.

PS: Your "amazing" friend does not account for any of the presuppositions he uses, like good or evil, truth or untruth, purpose or non purpose, better or worse, reason or non-reason, the character of Christians...he blindly assumes them and then stumbles forward into a kindergarten presentation of atheist talking points that have been refuted so many times that even professional atheist philosophers are ashamed to use them in formal debate. His knowledge of history is astonishingly ignorant or willfully dishonest. Most ethically sound? It is laughable.

[Gman]

Excuse me? And how did you come to that conclusion? You think that it is more logical that a bunch of subatomic particles just happened to exist and be the right size and charge to form atoms that just happened to make the right chemicals to make a planet and proteins that then just happened to form cells all on their own and then just happened to come to life... yeah real logical and makes tons of sense to me. And now those atoms are talking to you and arguing that that is not the case, they have also become self aware on their own.

How does this sound, instead of putting a youtube video up why don't you explain in detail why you said that. Please, enlighten me.

Apparently mud has creative properties... Given a little time and some gamma rays, it can create an entire city of people by itself.

[Imperial]

Atheism = Logical with some Proof

Christianity = Highly illogical, fairy tale'ish, impossible to prove (no proof at all)

Excuse me? And how did you come to that conclusion? You think that it is more logical that a bunch of subatomic particles just happened to exist and be the right size and charge to form atoms that just happened to make the right chemicals to make a planet and proteins that then just happened to form cells all on their own and then just happened to come to life... yeah real logical and makes tons of sense to me. And now those atoms are talking to you and arguing that that is not the case, they have also become self aware on their own.

How does this sound, instead of putting a youtube video up why don't you explain in detail why you said that. Please, enlighten me.

And you believe in some sort of all powerful being when nothing super natural has happened within confirmed recorded history? No miracles when we have all this disease and evil in the world? And all you're basing your beliefs on is a ridiculously old book which you can't even prove who actually came up with all the fairy tales inside? And you believe that a senior citizen rounded up all the species of animals on the earth into a giant boat which he built and survived a worldwide flood? And your only defense to why people should believe all this crap is that "You have Faith"??? No Proof????? Ya THAT'S logical

I didn't come up with everything in the youtube video, i didn't realize how insane i was getting until i watched the video. And if you watched the video, it had nothing to do with the origin of humans. NO ONE can truely say or prove what our origin is. NO ONE! Although scientists at least use real evidence that we have today to form THEORIES. (if you didn't know.. it's called the Big Bang THEORY - as in not proven but somthing along the lines that COULD happen)


The video said it all. I dont know what you want me to tell you.

[Gman]

So while we are on the topic, please prove your statement "Atheism = Logical with some proof" to be true. Be sure to include how you arrive at the laws of logic in the first place, and also show the proof for atheism that you talk about.

Too true.. Atheism is just another religion in itself.. It's practically entirely faith based...

[Imperial]

So while we are on the topic, please prove your statement "Atheism = Logical with some proof" to be true. Be sure to include how you arrive at the laws of logic in the first place, and also show the proof for atheism that you talk about.

Atheism believes in what can be proven. Theories are theories, i love how Gman assumes that Atheists believe in the big bang theory and societys spawning up from mud as if it was what REALLY happened.

Atheisms DON'T believe in an amazingly old book that shows all these unprovable fairy tales. When you look at real life today, how can ANY of that crap be plausable? That's Logical

[August]

And you believe in some sort of all powerful being when nothing super natural has happened within confirmed recorded history? No miracles when we have all this disease and evil in the world?

How do you know nothing super-natural has happened? How do you know no miracles have happened?

On what basis do you view "natural" explanations as the only valid explanations?

[Gabrielman]

Imperial before I respond to you...

READ THE MAIN SITE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

It will answer many of your very weak criticisms.

[Imperial]

And you believe in some sort of all powerful being when nothing super natural has happened within confirmed recorded history? No miracles when we have all this disease and evil in the world?

How do you know nothing super-natural has happened? How do you know no miracles have happened?

On what basis do you view "natural" explanations as the only valid explanations?

Oh ya.... I just read Harry Potter last week and dude its so plausable i bet there are wizards out there for real who gave someone the idea to make a movie and book of their ways to silently show the world what they could do.

^ Ya... That's basically what christianity is

[August]

So while we are on the topic, please prove your statement "Atheism = Logical with some proof" to be true. Be sure to include how you arrive at the laws of logic in the first place, and also show the proof for atheism that you talk about.

Atheism believes in what can be proven. Theories are theories, i love how Gman assumes that Atheists believe in the big bang theory and societys spawning up from mud as if it was what REALLY happened.

Atheisms DON'T believe in an amazingly old book that shows all these unprovable fairy tales. When you look at real life today, how can ANY of that crap be plausable? That's Logical

Please answer the question.

Also, please describe "what can be proven". What are your demarcations for proof? What is your explanatory filter?

"Theories are theories" is a tautology.

You keep using "logical" but have not yet shown where logic comes from...why we should believe you when you use it.

Your total argument against Christianity here is composed of logical fallacies, yet you claim to want to hold to logic.

[August]

And you believe in some sort of all powerful being when nothing super natural has happened within confirmed recorded history? No miracles when we have all this disease and evil in the world?

How do you know nothing super-natural has happened? How do you know no miracles have happened?

On what basis do you view "natural" explanations as the only valid explanations?

Oh ya.... I just read Harry Potter last week and dude its so plausable i bet there are wizards out there for real who gave someone the idea to make a movie and book of their ways to silently show the world what they could do.

^ Ya... That's basically what christianity is

This is getting repetitive...are you going to answer the questions? Or are you going to persist with your logical fallacies?

[Gman]

Atheism believes in what can be proven. Theories are theories, i love how Gman assumes that Atheists believe in the big bang theory and societys spawning up from mud as if it was what REALLY happened.

It's no wonder.. The big bang is direct evidence against atheism... The big bang states that the universe had a beginning..

Atheisms DON'T believe in an amazingly old book that shows all these unprovable fairy tales. When you look at real life today, how can ANY of that crap be plausable? That's Logical

Right, you believe that there isn't a god.. So the only other alternative is mud..

Say hello to your god of miracles... Worship it all the days of your life then..

[Gabrielman]

And you believe in some sort of all powerful being when nothing super natural has happened within confirmed recorded history?

Confirmed recorded history, as in....? So you mean back when people were first worshiping Jesus (oh I don't know, say not long after He came back from the dead) are not considered as part of recorded history? And how do you know nothing supernatural happens, even today it can happen. Of course you will attempt to write it off as some phenomenon that people just misunderstand, and yet for some odd reason you have no proof for that... but it is more logically sound than it being a supernatural happening. Sure.....

No miracles when we have all this disease and evil in the world?

Um... no miracles huh... so what do you call child birth and those atoms coming to life? And look online people testify to miracles every day.

And all you're basing your beliefs on is a ridiculously old book which you can't even prove who actually came up with all the fairy tales inside?

Uh... wow so you really don't know much about the Bible and the history behind it do you? Read this stuff and then get back to me

And you believe that a senior citizen rounded up all the species of animals on the earth into a giant boat which he built and survived a worldwide flood?

The flood was local, look it up.

I didn't come up with everything in the youtube video, i didn't realize how insane i was getting until i watched the video. And if you watched the video, it had nothing to do with the origin of humans. NO ONE can truely say or prove what our origin is. NO ONE! Although scientists at least use real evidence that we have today to form THEORIES. (if you didn't know.. it's called the Big Bang THEORY - as in not proven but somthing along the lines that COULD happen)

First of all I didn't say you came up with all of this, I asked you to provide evidence of your own as to why we are wrong, still you have not done that. And without the origin of humankind you have no foundation, so nothing to base it all on. Oh and I am not against the big bang, I believe God used it to make the universe, so why not study up on OEC (Old Earth Creationism) and get back to me on this too.