Re: Free Will
Posted: Fri Nov 09, 2012 9:44 pm
Skinner (or any determinist) would say that any experience of agency is illusory. Therefore, while one may think that one is expressing free will by choosing a favorite color, Skinner would say that that something in your history shaped your mind to choose that color. We would not be able to choose how determinism affects us because we don't actually make choices, we just have the illusory experience of making a choice. As jlay mentioned, however, if a deterministic account of the mind is true, there is no way to demonstrate it; if determinism is true, one's belief in the truth of determinism has little to do with that truth, but is merely the result of one's conditioning. On determinism, we really don't think at all; neurons simply fire mechanisticaly in response to stimuli, and the experience of "thought" is simply a curious epiphenomenon.