Re: Can of worms...
Posted: Thu Feb 04, 2016 1:08 am
Thank you for your response Jac, K and BW (RickD - no apology necessary, I like banter - just wanted to get the thread back on track)
I totally see what you are all saying. I done a fair bit of research in this over the last few days and this is what I have discovered.
Using this link http://godswordtowomen.org/Preato2.htm
There are three possible interpretations
1) It is a declarative statement from Paul.
This could even mean that Paul was being rather sexist here and just agree with the culture of the time and meant it universally to tie in with Rabbinic Jewish Tradition - or there was a problem with women in Corinth at the time and Paul wanted to address that specifically. If it is a declarative statement then the latter seems likely to fit in more with Paul's character because in most of his letters he extols women and does not come across as sexist.
2) As Jac says, it is an interpolation
These words are not consistent with Paul's character of style of writing - especially when you consider that in every instance when Paul talks about the law - he says "As it is written" and then goes onto directly quote scripture. This does not happen here - so this does not seem to be Paul's writing. Also this blatantly contradicts 1 Corinthians 11 where Paul states that it is okay to pray and prophesy. This also contradicts what Paul is saying in Galatians 2:26-29
As with the quote in Timothy - this link really gives a good interpretation of this
http://godswordtowomen.org/fees.htm
Scroll down to the bit that starts - Scripture is Finally Explained--I Timothy 2:11-14
I think this explains this passage very well personally. Also this you tube video covers it quite well
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CDHm7up ... WJRlgZ7eZg
It does make me think that if these interpretations are right then a lot of damage has been done by the church with regards to woman's ministry and a lot of potential for teaching and spreading the Gospel has been lost. Remember even Genesis 3:16, which a lot of anti-women minsters like to quote - was meant as a punishment from God, not the norm.
What do people think?
I totally see what you are all saying. I done a fair bit of research in this over the last few days and this is what I have discovered.
Using this link http://godswordtowomen.org/Preato2.htm
There are three possible interpretations
1) It is a declarative statement from Paul.
This could even mean that Paul was being rather sexist here and just agree with the culture of the time and meant it universally to tie in with Rabbinic Jewish Tradition - or there was a problem with women in Corinth at the time and Paul wanted to address that specifically. If it is a declarative statement then the latter seems likely to fit in more with Paul's character because in most of his letters he extols women and does not come across as sexist.
2) As Jac says, it is an interpolation
These words are not consistent with Paul's character of style of writing - especially when you consider that in every instance when Paul talks about the law - he says "As it is written" and then goes onto directly quote scripture. This does not happen here - so this does not seem to be Paul's writing. Also this blatantly contradicts 1 Corinthians 11 where Paul states that it is okay to pray and prophesy. This also contradicts what Paul is saying in Galatians 2:26-29
Being an interpolation however, does not sit comfortably with me as I am more inclined to believe in the inerrancy of the Bible. So I prefer the third option - which is that Paul was quoting a Corinthian quote or slogan straight back at them and then rebuking them in verse 36 - the NLT puts is like this26 So in Christ Jesus you are all children of God through faith, 27 for all of you who were baptized into Christ have clothed yourselves with Christ. 28 There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus. 29 If you belong to Christ, then you are Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise.
With this in mind and referring back to what was said about option 2 - this is not Paul's writing but a quotation and Paul was then rebuking them. I like this idea.36 Or do you think God’s word originated with you Corinthians? Are you the only ones to whom it was given?
As with the quote in Timothy - this link really gives a good interpretation of this
http://godswordtowomen.org/fees.htm
Scroll down to the bit that starts - Scripture is Finally Explained--I Timothy 2:11-14
I think this explains this passage very well personally. Also this you tube video covers it quite well
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CDHm7up ... WJRlgZ7eZg
It does make me think that if these interpretations are right then a lot of damage has been done by the church with regards to woman's ministry and a lot of potential for teaching and spreading the Gospel has been lost. Remember even Genesis 3:16, which a lot of anti-women minsters like to quote - was meant as a punishment from God, not the norm.
What do people think?