Page 3 of 7

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Wed May 30, 2012 4:13 pm
by RickD
BavarianWheels wrote:
RickD wrote:BavarianWheels wrote:
Salvation is first and foremost a legal action brought about by love. We are declared righteous through Christ's death, not through God's love. If it was the latter, God wouldn't have had to die.
Again, this gets back to how one sees the nature of God. I certainly don't see salvation as "first and foremost" a legal action. I see salvation as a gift to all mankind, by a loving God. John 3:16 “For God so loved the world, that He gave His [a] only begotten Son, that whoever believes in Him shall not perish, but have eternal life.

We are declared righteous through Christ's work. And Christ's work was done for us, because of God's love for us. God loved us so much, that He died for us. You can't have the death, without the love.
I would agree, however for salvation to work, it must be legal. If the Law demands perfection, then perfection is only what satisfies the Law...else why would Christ/God have to die? If it was any death, then God wouldn't have had to die Himself. He legally took on our punishment that we wouldn't have to. Legally...first, but through love as the catalyst for the action.

Notice that God loved the world, gave His son and belief is necessary for salvation. It's a legal process. That's why the bible speaks of contracts, wills, covenants, Law demands, breaking of Law, wages of sin, punishment...these are all legal terms.
.
.
Bav, I have no problem with belief(faith in Christ) being necessary for salvation. That's what I believe. I guess in what you're saying above, I don't look at salvation as a legal process. I just simply look at salvation as a gift from God, through the work of Christ. The Bible doesn't say believe on the work of Christ, as a legal process, in order to be saved. Although a legal process, is probably one way of looking at it. And, I hope you're not implying that I believe faith in someone else(besides Christ's) work, would merit salvation.
I'm simply saying that I leave open the possibility that if one dies without ever hearing the gospel, then there may be some other way God judges that person. I just don't presume to say that everyone that hasn't even heard of Jesus Christ, is automatically bound for hell.

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Wed May 30, 2012 4:56 pm
by Furstentum Liechtenstein
PaulSacramento wrote:What I am simply stating is MY belief that God gives ALL people a chance to repent, that is simply what I am stating.
You are correct. All have a chance to repent here, on earth, before they die. After that, Heb 9:27

Have you read and understood Romans 1-2-3 where God condemns all: first the pagans, then Israel, then the Gentiles?
PaulSacramento wrote:I don't believe that, since that would have condemend so many people through out history, arguably even the likes of Moses and such since he did NOT know about Christ.
You have an incorrect understanding here. Faith is believing God, taking Him at His word, Abraham believed God and it was imputed to him for righteousness applies to Moses, to David, to all the OT saints who died without knowing Messiah Jesus. Ro 5: 1-2 sums up this idea of a saving faith marvelously: Therefore, since we have been justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ, through whom we have gained access by faith into this grace which we now stand...
PaulSacramento wrote:Yes, I am suggesting that there may still be a chance for salvation after death, at the resurrection and final judgment.
The Final Judgement described in Rev 20:11-15 is a judgement for the unsaved. You have that right. Where you go wrong is assuming that there will be a second chance to accept Jesus at the Great White Throne Judgement described in Rev 20. This judgement is to apportion punishment, and suggests differeing levels of torment for sinners according to how they have sinned. You may want to study Heb 2:2 in conjunction with this, ...every transgression and disobedience [will receive] a just reward. Daniel 12:2, John 5:28-29 and Acts 24:15 may also help you understand the difference between the resurrection of the just and the resurrection of the unjust.
PaulSacramento wrote:As one atheist said to me when he heard similar things like what has been written here: "Why on Earth would I want to believe in a God like that?"
The Bible will always - and in all ways - be unacceptable to the damned. It is not up to a Christian to make it more pallatable to the unsaved by softening it up and inventing stuff. There is no second chance. Now that you know, stop repeating this so that you don't unwittingly contribute to the damnation of someone.

FL

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Wed May 30, 2012 7:06 pm
by Ivellious
FL, just for the record, when a man in India drowns his baby daughter in the river because he wants a son, your God willfully and "righteously" condemns her soul to eternal damnation because she has not accepted Jesus Christ? Literally every person aside from the prophets of the OT as well?

Again, if this is what Christianity teaches, then I wouldn't want to be a part of the club either. I'd much rather avoid being grouped with any person who believes that God gives no second chance to those who have had literally no chance to ever know Jesus.

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Wed May 30, 2012 7:11 pm
by Danieltwotwenty
Ivellious wrote:FL, just for the record, when a man in India drowns his baby daughter in the river because he wants a son, your God willfully and "righteously" condemns her soul to eternal damnation because she has not accepted Jesus Christ? Literally every person aside from the prophets of the OT as well?

Again, if this is what Christianity teaches, then I wouldn't want to be a part of the club either. I'd much rather avoid being grouped with any person who believes that God gives no second chance to those who have had literally no chance to ever know Jesus.

Matthew 19:14 - Jesus said, "Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these."

Indicates that Children are saved as they are not capable of making a choice yet. The Bible also talks about the age of reason but I can't find the passage (little help).


Dan

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Wed May 30, 2012 7:19 pm
by Ivellious
Well, I'll give you credit, that answers my question. It's still baffling to me how one could hold someone responsible for not taking advantage of an opportunity not given to them. A more apt example: A young boy is raised in seclusion by Buddhist monks. Rarely leaves his monastery and dies at a fairly young age from cancer. Or, again, everyone who wasn't a prophet prior to Jesus's life. And even then, the millions (possibly billions) of people during and after Jesus's life who lived outside the middle east and never heard of Jesus.

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Wed May 30, 2012 7:22 pm
by Danieltwotwenty
Ivellious wrote:Well, I'll give you credit, that answers my question. It's still baffling to me how one could hold someone responsible for not taking advantage of an opportunity not given to them. A more apt example: A young boy is raised in seclusion by Buddhist monks. Rarely leaves his monastery and dies at a fairly young age from cancer. Or, again, everyone who wasn't a prophet prior to Jesus's life. And even then, the millions (possibly billions) of people during and after Jesus's life who lived outside the middle east and never heard of Jesus.

Your asking a question that we (humans) cannot answer because we just don't know, only God know that persons heart and God will judge righteously based on what knowledge they have.

It's like saying Hitler was a Christian because he said he was, really we have no idea what he believed as only him and God know.

Dan

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Wed May 30, 2012 7:25 pm
by Ivellious
Well, FL is saying exactly what I just said, and apparently has quotes to prove it. I certainly know not all Christians feel that way, but FL says it is fact. And also, to be honest, I think it would be equally sick if God forgave Hitler. I mean, it would be pretty sad to see Gandhi burning eternally in Hell while Hitler lived an eternity of joy and happiness...I mean, for that to even be a possibility is so wrong.

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Wed May 30, 2012 7:33 pm
by Danieltwotwenty
Ivellious wrote:Well, FL is saying exactly what I just said, and apparently has quotes to prove it. I certainly know not all Christians feel that way, but FL says it is fact. And also, to be honest, I think it would be equally sick if God forgave Hitler. I mean, it would be pretty sad to see Gandhi burning eternally in Hell while Hitler lived an eternity of joy and happiness...I mean, for that to even be a possibility is so wrong.

Well I shall let FL speak for himself.

It's best not to think about who will be there and who will not, the only persons salvation you should be concerned with at the moment is your own, or your just getting bogged down in hypotheticals which bear no fruit.
Once that is secured then spread the word to everyone else.

Dan

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Wed May 30, 2012 9:17 pm
by 1over137
Danieltwotwenty wrote: It's best not to think about who will be there and who will not, the only persons salvation you should be concerned with at the moment is your own, or your just getting bogged down in hypotheticals which bear no fruit.
Once that is secured then spread the word to everyone else.
Yes, one could get lost in hypotheticals. I can only speak for friends I know. I think that they had hurting experience when they were children but since God is just I believe and hope that they will be shown true love on this earth. Did I really know some unbelievers who died? No, I didn't and hope that will not do. May I be the means to achieve that? Sure, I may.

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Thu May 31, 2012 2:13 am
by Furstentum Liechtenstein
Ivellious wrote:I certainly know not all Christians feel that way, but FL says it is fact.
I'm not saying it is fact. I'm nobody. A plain reading of the Bible is all I've been promoting.
Ivellious wrote: It's still baffling to me how one could hold someone responsible for not taking advantage of an opportunity not given to them. A more apt example: A young boy is raised in seclusion by Buddhist monks. Rarely leaves his monastery and dies at a fairly young age from cancer. Or, again, everyone who wasn't a prophet prior to Jesus's life. And even then, the millions (possibly billions) of people during and after Jesus's life who lived outside the middle east and never heard of Jesus.
Anyone anywhere who sincerely searches for God will be found by Him, and God will reveal Himself to true seekers. This includes your secluded boy raised by Buddhist monks. Have you not read and understood what I've already wrote on this? If God saved - that is , made righteous - Abraham (who never heard of Jesus), God will save anyone who has faith in Him. Not faith in Buddha or Vishnu or Allah or Ahura Mazda, but faith in the one and only God of the Bible.

I know of Muslims, atheists and Jews who've come to a saving faith in Christ through an earnest search of the Scriptures. It can happen to you too.

FL

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Thu May 31, 2012 3:25 am
by neo-x
Ivellious wrote:
Well, FL is saying exactly what I just said, and apparently has quotes to prove it. I certainly know not all Christians feel that way, but FL says it is fact. And also, to be honest, I think it would be equally sick if God forgave Hitler. I mean, it would be pretty sad to see Gandhi burning eternally in Hell while Hitler lived an eternity of joy and happiness...I mean, for that to even be a possibility is so wrong.
Why do you think that God forgiving Hitler sick or Gandhi burning in hell is unacceptable. While the former was a madman, the latter was almost a saint as far as actions are concerned but regardless of what those people did, you can not out-weigh grace by works. That is the point of which I think you have, IMHO, a superficial understanding, Ivel. No offense but it shows. The gospel is not about what you did, but about what Christ did. You are seeing it the other way around through some sort of karma that is working behind the scene, well that ain't the gospel and it certainly isn't Christianity either.

As far as sin is concerned, your daily lies (just for sake of example), my adulterous routine, Hitler's bloodthirsty war, Gandhi's unbelief are all equal. One sin is as punishable as is the other, although we can logically argue that such is not the case in human courts but in christian doctrine, all sin is sin and ultimately, however innocent it may seem, leads to only one outcome, death. Why? because God is perfect, and in such his standards are perfect too. No man, you, me and the pope included, can follow it 100%. That is why the lie is as unacceptable as rape. That is the whole point of Christ's coming down to earth and dying like a sinner. Because he being perfect can die in your place, and he did die in your place, for your sins and mine.

No true christian is saved by his works, as no Hitler is condemned just because he is a mass-killer, if you do not believe in Christ, you are not atoned. If you re not atoned, no matter how good you are, you sin, as all human beings do, so even if you are good, in god's eyes it is not complete. This is the prime difference between grace and the law. You are going through it like an accountant but you have to see it through grace. Grace in Christ's message means one thing, you are not being treated according to your works. Therefore, a christian who is arrogant is as much of a sinner as an atheist who murdered his neighbor. And therefore both can be saved though grace, which is obtained by Christ work on the Cross.

The question about Hitler and Gandhi, will they be saved? is irrelevant, not because they are good or bad people, but because they have not been atoned. Their sins are on them.

Personally, and I would concur with you that a man like Hitler should never be granted mercy, but in front of God, if I hate my brother, I am as guilty as Hitler. You have to understand divine justice, and how it operates. One sin is equal to death so is ten million sins. It is like, if a man murders 14 people you can only hang him once, right? what if he kills in prison too, a fellow inmate, can you hang him twice? No he will die once, no matter how many sins he did. To some extent, the same is the case here. If you sin, you sin, whether you sin 100 times or 1 million times, its irrelevant. we die spiritually because of sin.

Therefore when Christ came, he sat down with drunkards, tax collectors, corrupt officials, prostitutes and so on and so forth. For people thought, just like you, they were rating sin. Their daily small lies were, in their eyes much less than the prostitutes vulgarity, which she practices day and night. So in their own eyes they were more good than others. But Christ gave the alternate message, its not about how good you are. its about what you lack, and we all lack, therefore we can not fulfill the righteous standard of God and therefore no matter how good or bad we are, we fall short of the mark, including you and me.

Where is justice then? you ask. Justice is done not on your works, but on Christ's. For if God judges us on our own merit, we all will be condemned, everyone, holy Christians and Jews included. And so on the bright side, to be saved all you need to come to Christ and accept him as your savior.

And God is not unjust, he may not judge by our standards but then if we accept the idea of God being the ultimate authority, then he cant be contested, can he now? But by unjust I mean, first, as Dan clarified, children who die without knowing Christ are not condemned.

This is just a in-a-nutshell explanation. I hope you understand what I am saying. I needed to point out your misunderstanding since it will now help you better understand of how Christ views, sin, justice and therefore grace, which is for all of us and by that alone we are saved. If we come to Christ with our sins, we can be absolved of the penalty there of, if we believe in him, as our savior and lord.

P.S this is for the rest of the Christian members here, i have posted to clarify Ivel, what he did not seem to know. I do not want my message now to turn into a Calvinism vs Arminianism debate, about how we are saved, and who is saved etc, that is not my intention here and neither will I dive into it.

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Thu May 31, 2012 5:08 am
by RickD
Amen, neo-x. I think you did a great job explaining.

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Thu May 31, 2012 5:39 am
by PaulSacramento
RickD wrote:I certainly understand what you're saying, Paul. I just don't know what will happen to those who haven't had a chance to accept or reject Christ. I have a difficult time believing that first, all people hear the gospel before they die. And, second, those that haven't heard the good news, are automatically on their way to hell. I just can't say that those who haven't heard of Jesus Christ, are eternally doomed, without a chance to reject God. Again, I believe this gets back to what one believes about the nature of God. I'm just leaving room for the possibility that God, in His unmerited love, will give all people a chance to accept Him. Even those, for whatever reason, haven't heard the gospel before they die. Is it possible that anyone that hasn't accepted Christ, even those who haven't heard the gospel, are doomed to hell? Sure, that's possible. Then my belief about the nature of God, and His love, is wrong. Maybe that's what FL would call a "Froot Loop" theology. BTW, Froot Loops is my favorite cereal. ;)
I have no issues with, as CS Lewis put it: We either say to God "They will be done" or God says to us,"thy will be done".
BUT for that to be ONE must KNOW God.

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Thu May 31, 2012 5:48 am
by PaulSacramento
Its funny that http://biblia.com/bible/nasb95/John%205.28-29 has been quoted, since it seems to say that:
The the resurrected will be judged by their deeds and those that have done good will be resurrected to Life.
It doesn't say those that have beleived in Christ ALONE are ressurected to life, but those that have done good.
It echos to Jesus' parable of the goats and sheep.
It seems to me that those that don't believe in Christ will be judged on their deeds, as those who do will be saved by their faith.

Re: Loved Ones and Heaven

Posted: Thu May 31, 2012 5:09 pm
by Furstentum Liechtenstein
PaulSacramento wrote:It seems to me that those that don't believe in Christ will be judged on their deeds, as those who do will be saved by their faith.
You are correct, but do you understand the implication of what you have posted?

There are two resurrections, one for the saved, where they will be rewarded for their acts performed in the faith; and one for the unsaved, where they will be judged according to their acts. Those without a saving faith have ''good deeds'' that are as filthy rags in the sight of God (Isa 64:6). Such good deeds are worthless, absolutely worthless.

Also, please read & study neo-x's post.

FL