Re: Infinite punishment for finite sins
Posted: Wed Oct 06, 2010 12:28 am
Hi Sudsy!
You say that…
It is not simply the interpretation of many Christians…It is God’s word and his guidance, that’s why so many believe it….
It is just as plan to me as reading a book that says-Throw that bass in the garbage, it looks bad and all the frets are broken.
It is perfectly clear that we are talking about the bass instrument. If it just said: Throw that bass in the garbage, it looks bad.
Then we can choose what we want to believe. It can either mean the bass instrument or a big smelly rotten fish, you are free to choose. But because the words-and all the frets are broken. Are in the same sentence as bass, it can only mean the bass instrument.
Concerning hell, it is not what I or many other countless Christians wish to believe. Because of the context in which the word eternal is used in relation to hell plus the interpretation of various metaphors meaning the same, the context in which the word is used in many other scriptures, God’s character etc. It can only mean eternal as in infinite… There is no choice concerning the matter, only the choice to believe what one wishes to believe despite what the bible says.
Also, it is important to do our best to keep God’s word as it is, because he knows best. All decisions (and I do mean all) have a moral belief attached to them. No matter what one decides, their decision to choose or not to choose one idea, belief or action etc over another will be made because the decision-maker feels it’s right or wrong. Their belief that something is right or wrong will be weighed against God’s beliefs. There is a reason why we all make the choices we do in life. One simply does not believe in something for no reason. The why and the intent are very important to God. And his word is made to help and aid us in many areas. His word will cause many feelings, resistance, peace, joy, worrier etc. But it is all good and causes us to keep searching for the truth, not only the truth behind his words but the truth in our heart.
No, no…..I did not misunderstand you. I know your argument well Sudsy. Ministry is my life, this is nothing new to me at all. And no, it does not matter what the majority of Christianity says. It matters what the bible says…Sudsy wrote:J. Davis, I see you have completely mis-understood the point I was making regarding the word 'eternal'.
You say that…
I know the whole game as far as people playing with the Greek word that translates to eternal. That’s why I said you are not using the correct scriptures. However, what is important is the context in which a word is used. Words can mean many things depending on the context in which the word is used. And there is no way at all that eternal, given the context that it is used in concerning hell means a finite period of time/ age or period. No way, no how, whatsoever…period. I know you are new to this just from the defense and scriptures you bring up. But if you want to make your reasoning work than you are going to wind up changing TONS of scriptures in a way that makes no sense. And the end, using your reasoning, should I or anyone who has done this a lot, debate against you concerning your beliefs, will end in there being no God.Sudsy wrote:I see the term 'eternal' in many ways referring to an age or period that does not mean eternal in the sense that God always was and always will be.
It is not simply the interpretation of many Christians…It is God’s word and his guidance, that’s why so many believe it….
It is just as plan to me as reading a book that says-Throw that bass in the garbage, it looks bad and all the frets are broken.
It is perfectly clear that we are talking about the bass instrument. If it just said: Throw that bass in the garbage, it looks bad.
Then we can choose what we want to believe. It can either mean the bass instrument or a big smelly rotten fish, you are free to choose. But because the words-and all the frets are broken. Are in the same sentence as bass, it can only mean the bass instrument.
Concerning hell, it is not what I or many other countless Christians wish to believe. Because of the context in which the word eternal is used in relation to hell plus the interpretation of various metaphors meaning the same, the context in which the word is used in many other scriptures, God’s character etc. It can only mean eternal as in infinite… There is no choice concerning the matter, only the choice to believe what one wishes to believe despite what the bible says.
Also, it is important to do our best to keep God’s word as it is, because he knows best. All decisions (and I do mean all) have a moral belief attached to them. No matter what one decides, their decision to choose or not to choose one idea, belief or action etc over another will be made because the decision-maker feels it’s right or wrong. Their belief that something is right or wrong will be weighed against God’s beliefs. There is a reason why we all make the choices we do in life. One simply does not believe in something for no reason. The why and the intent are very important to God. And his word is made to help and aid us in many areas. His word will cause many feelings, resistance, peace, joy, worrier etc. But it is all good and causes us to keep searching for the truth, not only the truth behind his words but the truth in our heart.