Re: Is this President really this ignorant? ISIS=The Crusad
Posted: Fri Feb 27, 2015 5:41 pm
Okay, Daniel. I'm not going to contribute to this any further, and I want to be clear why. There is nothing wrong with having strong disagreements on matters of foreign policy, on any policy. There's nothing wrong with having strong differences on moral issues. But when you disagreement becomes the kind of rhetoric where you are making immoral comparisons and actively slandering others--especially fellow members of the body of Christ--then what you are engaging in is no longer (heated) debate, but rather sin. And make no mistake, what you've done above is sin. I see a parallel here between your comments and the recent comments by Scott Walker in which he compared the roughly 100,000 American protestors who opposed his public union policies with ISIS fighters. He later backed off he remarks and tried to explain them away, but it was precisely because the comparison was so vile. In a similar way, you've resorted demeaning others and comparing them to the worst kind of evil on the planet today. You may as well have said evangelicals are Nazis. It's disgusting, and that is the kind of rhetoric that ought not be tolerated.
Given all that, and because I know you aren't going to back down off this, I'm not going to present you with further cause to sin. I get that you are very deeply opposed to war of all kinds. While I deeply disagree with your position, I can at least respect it as a position that many people and great saints have held. But your opposition is causing you to slander others, and frankly, I don't think this is something you are capable of discussing in a matter that isn't self-condemning.
On a final note, none of this says anything about my personal respect for you. I'm not so robotic as to pretend like your lumping "evangelicals" (even "intolerant evangelicals") in with murderers doesn't affect me. I am an evangelical, and one you might well call "intolerant." So your remarks here are highly offensive. But with that said, all of us--starting with me as you well know--have said stupid things, and I'm not so blinded by all this as to think that you actually think of me in such slanderous terms. So I can hear and deal with my own emotional reaction. I say all that because I don't want to give you the wrong idea here. I'm not posting out of anger, but I'm also not pretending that I'm posting from some objective place in which I can make dispassionate rulings from on high. I'm human, too. I just think that, despite my offense, I'm terribly concerned about what I see to be as a serious sin on your part. I hope and pray that you'll reconsider your rhetoric if not your position. But either way, again, I don't want to be a further cause to stumble, and I don't want this to get out of hand and the mods have to get involved. Peace and fellowship ought not be violated, so it is in those interests that I'm bowing out here.
Given all that, and because I know you aren't going to back down off this, I'm not going to present you with further cause to sin. I get that you are very deeply opposed to war of all kinds. While I deeply disagree with your position, I can at least respect it as a position that many people and great saints have held. But your opposition is causing you to slander others, and frankly, I don't think this is something you are capable of discussing in a matter that isn't self-condemning.
On a final note, none of this says anything about my personal respect for you. I'm not so robotic as to pretend like your lumping "evangelicals" (even "intolerant evangelicals") in with murderers doesn't affect me. I am an evangelical, and one you might well call "intolerant." So your remarks here are highly offensive. But with that said, all of us--starting with me as you well know--have said stupid things, and I'm not so blinded by all this as to think that you actually think of me in such slanderous terms. So I can hear and deal with my own emotional reaction. I say all that because I don't want to give you the wrong idea here. I'm not posting out of anger, but I'm also not pretending that I'm posting from some objective place in which I can make dispassionate rulings from on high. I'm human, too. I just think that, despite my offense, I'm terribly concerned about what I see to be as a serious sin on your part. I hope and pray that you'll reconsider your rhetoric if not your position. But either way, again, I don't want to be a further cause to stumble, and I don't want this to get out of hand and the mods have to get involved. Peace and fellowship ought not be violated, so it is in those interests that I'm bowing out here.