How do you know you are right?
Posted: Sat Sep 24, 2005 8:41 pm
How are you certain that Christianity is right and thousands of other religions are wrong? Have you ever considered other religions?
"The heavens declare the glory of God; the skies proclaim the work of his hands." (Psalm 19:1)
https://discussions.godandscience.org/
Well, I never said that someone had to be a moron to be Christian. But you still didn't answer my question. Why is christianity the correct religion while muslims, jews, hidus, buddhists, etc are wrong? What makes you believe beyond a shadow of a doubt that you chose the correct religion?Judah wrote:Part of the certainty comes from considering the claims of other religions and finding them to be wanting.
Much of the certainty comes from considering the claims of Christianity and finding them to have a high level of integrity, rationality, consistency, and substantial truth.
To believe the claims of Christianity does not require that you drop 30 IQ points, abandon your brain, and accept some kind of senseless empty faith. Indeed, given the substantial amount of excellent "apologia" for Christianity, it could be said that perhaps the most intelligent response to the claims of Christianity is in fact to believe them.
I'm not sure what any of this has to do with why christianity is the correct religion. I am very familar with Christianity, I don't need a lesson.Deborah wrote:Christianity was the name assigned by the Romans in Antioch whom were NOT believers.
The underlying lesson the bible keeps coming back to is
Love each other.
John 15:17
This is my command: Love each other.
Jesus commanded that we love instead of hate, and what is more he showed us how, but too many of us are too blind to see.
The latin Bible translator, and biblical scholar Jerome, said that Church tradition said that, when John, son of Zebadee and brother of James was an old man, his disciples would carry him to church in their arms.
He would simply say, “Little children, love one another”
After a time his disciples wearied at always hearing these same words and asked “Master why do you always say this?
He replied, “it is the Lords command, and if done, it is enough”
All teachings of the bible are important, but they all lead to this one.
If only we could master this one commandment .
John 15:12-17
12My command is this: Love each other as I have loved you. 13Greater love has no one than this, that he lay down his life for his friends. 14You are my friends if you do what I command. 15I no longer call you servants, because a servant does not know his master's business. Instead, I have called you friends, for everything that I learned from my Father I have made known to you. 16You did not choose me, but I chose you and appointed you to go and bear fruit—fruit that will last. Then the Father will give you whatever you ask in my name. 17This is my command: Love each other.
When I meet Jesus, the one thing I hope to hear him say is welcome friend.
Well, a Christian wouldn't have to know about all religions. My question is mostly theoretical and was meant to inspire thought. But, I do think it's important to at least look at the beliefs of other religions. Obviously not all of them because there are too many. The main reason for my question is that so many Christians are certain that their religion is right and all other religions are completely wrong. So I guess my question is, of all the monotheistic religions (mainly jeudism, muslim, deist) what has made you decide that Christianity is correct? You could say it's because the New Testiment says so.....but there are other religious texts that say otherwise. The Quran, for instance, claims that Jesus was just a prophet, not Christ.Kurieuo wrote:I believe the underlying claim behind your question is invalid. Can you please show us that your underlying premise is valid, that is, a Christian must know all religions in order to be justified that their Christian beliefs are true?
Kurieuo
I wouldn't say this is true. When a Christian claims another religion is false, I know with myself that I am not saying that everything within that other religion is wrong. Rather I asserting that those beliefs which are incompatible with my core Christian beliefs (e.g., a personal and righteous God's existence, Christ's divinity, Christ's death and resurrection, etc) are wrong, since of course the law of non-contradiction which isn't necessarily politically correct requires this.LV_Designs wrote:The main reason for my question is that so many Christians are certain that their religion is right and all other religions are completely wrong.
This slightly off topic, however in line with your response. I think it's safe to say that the main difference between Christians and Jews and Muslims is their idea of what jesus was. But the bible says that you have to accept christ as the savior in order to be forgiven of sins and go do heaven. Do you think this means that Jews and Muslims go to hell, even though they may otherwise be good people according biblical standards.Kurieuo wrote:I added a bit more to my post before you posted, but to respond to a further comment in your reply...
I wouldn't say this is true. When a Christian claims another religion is false, I know with myself that I am not saying that everything within that other religion is wrong. Rather I asserting that those beliefs which are incompatible with my core Christian beliefs (e.g., a personal and righteous God's existence, Christ's divinity, Christ's death and resurrection, etc) are wrong, since of course the law of non-contradiction which isn't necessarily politically correct requires this.LV_Designs wrote:The main reason for my question is that so many Christians are certain that their religion is right and all other religions are completely wrong.
Kurieuo
I disagree. I read that the Bible says we are all forgiven of our sins regardless of accepting Christ. Yet, that forgiveness which has already happened thanks to Christ, still remains to be received and experienced by those who are not aware to it, can't accept it, or who are running away from God. There is a good article I've quoted previously for others which you may want to read that clarifys this issue further (see Is Forgiveness Conditional OR Unconditional?).LV_Designs wrote:This slightly off topic, however in line with your response. I think it's safe to say that the main difference between Christians and Jews and Muslims is their idea of what jesus was. But the bible says that you have to accept christ as the savior in order to be forgiven of sins and go do heaven.
An underlying implication I detect in this question is that Christianity is somehow unfair? Yet, I have some comments. The first being that God will be judge of all, and even many Muslims and Jews would agree with this. My second comment is that if anyone is truly "good" then I have no hesitation in saying that such will receive eternal life with God. But Christ said only God is good, and if this is true, then we have a problem if God is good and we aren't compatible with His goodness.LV_Designs wrote:Do you think this means that Jews and Muslims go to hell, even though they may otherwise be good people according biblical standards.
I did answer your question broadly with my response that... "Much of the certainty comes from considering the claims of Christianity and finding them to have a high level of integrity, rationality, consistency, and substantial truth."LV_Designs wrote: Well, I never said that someone had to be a moron to be Christian. But you still didn't answer my question. Why is christianity the correct religion while muslims, jews, hidus, buddhists, etc are wrong? What makes you believe beyond a shadow of a doubt that you chose the correct religion?
Deborah wrote:Wrong the world needs a lesson including christians!
the lesson is love and nothing more!
The way I see it every single religion is hateful and intolerant, yet the teachings of Jesus are not. jesus was not a christian he was a Jew.
Faith has not changed, jesus came to bring us back to the correct way of life. that we should learn to love as the LORD God loves us, unconditionally.
You seem to be an intelligent individual, there is nothing which says you must conform to one relegion or another. I am sure you've read great books from Chaucer, Steinbeck, Kant, Einstein, Swift, etc... And I am sure you have learned from and respect the works of these great men. Regardless of you being a Christian or not. I will tell you that the lessons of Jesus are at least equal to those aformentioned men.LV_Designs wrote:But the bible says that you have to accept christ as the savior in order to be forgiven of sins and go do heaven. Do you think this means that Jews and Muslims go to hell, even though they may otherwise be good people according biblical standards.
I wouldn't call Christianity "unfair" but is fairness equated with truth? I read the article you posted. I can understand it saying that Atheists will face judgement, that's a given in this case. I think I'd be kinda pissed too if someone told me I don't exist. The article talked about God generically but was obviously implying the Christian God. There are people who believe in other versions of a monotheistic god, as well as those who believe is many gods. Some people believe in God but don't ascribe to a particular religion. Even some Buddhists believe in a god. Although the article did a good job in making it's point, it seemed to exclude anyone who was not raised as a Christian. If you were raised in a religion that worshiped a god, but not necessarily the Christian God, wouldn't you find asking for forgiveness from the Christian God slightly odd. You would think that your religion is right. This other religions that believes in some sort of monotheistic entity could easily have a loving god who can grant forgiveness without having to sacrifice himself to him self. This is essentially what happened God send Jesus (who is also God) to suffer for sins on the cross. Why was this necessary? It would be pretty simple for a powerful being such as God to simply forgive. You could say it is because he wanted only those who believe in him to receive forgiveness. But this would require that anyone who is to be forgiven accept Jesus as the savior. Look at the story from an outsider's perspective. Outside of the bible Jesus isn't mentioned as a savior. There are a couple other texts, such as the Quran, which view him as a prophet. Going even further, as far as I can fine, there are no records of Jesus in Roman crucifixion records or any other secular records. The idea of why God, being all powerful, would have to send Jesus to earth, perplexes me. Why did God create a world where forgiveness would be necessary in the first place? Ya, I know it's supposedly because man is sinful and Satan encourages man to act sinfully. But, an all powerful God would have known that man would be sinful when he started life. It's like allowing your child to run around in the mud then getting mad at him because he is dirty. You didn't necessarily tell him it was okay to run in the mud, but you allowed him to go where you knew he would get dirty. This seems to be what God did. He created an existence where getting "dirty" is inevitable, then gets upset when we get "dirty."Kurieuo wrote:An underlying implication I detect in this question is that Christianity is somehow unfair?LV_Designs wrote:Do you think this means that Jews and Muslims go to hell, even though they may otherwise be good people according biblical standards.