Gman wrote:Oriental
Thanks for the info... I'm pretty familiar with Hong Kong and China and realize the difference between the two.. However, I'm not too sure how Hong Kong is being governed now under the communist rule since it became part of mainline China in 1997.
After 1997. the Communist government has been keeping HK as independent city as possible and she never asks how it is governed. The problem is the
very independence while British government does not interfere as well, HK becomes some place quite dictated by merchants. Since the merchants and zillionaires always theatened to redomicile their economic base to somewhere else the government policy was always in favor of the wealthy people. Social welfare is quite ignored. Education is in mess.
Gman wrote:
From my understanding, the people of China have a choice now to either become part of the communist party there or be part of the capitalist party. Is this also true in HK now?
First of all, in China, there is only one party - Communist party. If an enterpeuner and millionaire in China tells you that he does not have political identity, he must be telling lies to you. (this is a taboo in China because Chinese government wants to cultivate some wealthy men and millionaire to
combat the foreigners; their racism is grave) All capitalists in China are actually
molded by Chinese government. (no new coverage can reveal this, because no one can tell you this truth with verification. I work in a non-state-owned enterprise in Beijing. It portrays itself a private firm. I tell you the truth: the human resource department in our firm is communist party's representative and only members of communist party can have decision making and be key members in the firm; in our language, we describe such guys are
politically righteous to be directors and senior management) It is nonsense in the viewpoint of HK people. However, it is career in Beijing people.
In HK, things are different. Freedom of speech and economy and politics, the government is packed with multi-parties. the poorest thing is absence of referendum and the political parties are elected by minority group, ousting quite a lot from voting.
Gman wrote:
On a different note.. I think I understand the work ethic there in China. The people there are very much respectful to the authorities and do not question them.. They also work very hard for them... I believe this tradition goes back thousands of years. The people are extremely grateful for their work and are humble to their rulers.. So it is no wonder how someone could gain power over the people of China and then lord themselves over the people because they know they will not fight back.. Having this Christ-like servant attitude is engrained in them.. But unfortunately certain people can take advantage of that..
You are correct in saying that people do not question the authorities (because they dare not); however it is not correct to say that they are respectful to the authorities. They bear grudge against the government. (because the places are impoverished and their living a life not as affluent as the expatriates'. It is true, however, that they don't have the nerve to complain. The authorities, the government, are actually
soldiers! They do not act with reasons but they act with force.
Other myths of your words include:
1) they work hard, not for the communist party, but for themselves, for power and money, and mostly, for glory and to avoid shame (I still can't find the biblical meaning of "glory and shame". the people here are highly sensitive to "glory and shame" and, precisely, "faces" which are their lives and hatred oozes if you are better than them, and they would combat against you, by whatever means, so that by comparison, they won't be worse than anyone, in whatever respect. Sometimes, they fail, so they can be highly frustrated if they can't win the "glory" and fall into "shame"
2) they are not grateful to their work and they are not humble to their rulers. They are highly aggressive; because communist party bullies the citizens, they are simply afraid of the political party which doesn't mean that they are grateful. If they tell you that they are grateful, they are simply telling lies to you to avoid taboo.
3) the peace in China when the citizens, as you said, won't fight back, is simply because: they are not armed, and second, they don't know how to fight. the social system doesn't bear any channel to complain and there is no ombudsmen (either the concept or the mechanism) to deal with complaints. When US government always hurled criticism against China for lack of human rights, US government is absolutely right. There is no freedom and human rights in China at all, because there is no knowledge of "human rights" amongst the citizens. They simply don't know what rights they should have but sheer pitiful ignorance and naive observance to the rules.
4) I don't think their attitude are Christ-like servant, because the observance ideology is actually likened to: millions of people loyal to one source - the communist party, but millions of people do not care about each other unless they fall within 5 kinds of relationship - kings and officers, father and sons, husband and wives, teacher and students, as well as friends and enemies. Strangers do not have any relationship amongst themselves. In Christianity, Jesus teaches us to love strangers and He died for strangers' sins. Samaritan parable about neighborhood love in Luke gospel does not exist in traditional value in China. Therefore, you may see that the streets and places in China are so dirty. People do not have love for strangers (they don't understand why they should love to keep clean the places where are not their homes at all! see?)
** the so-called 5 kinds of relationship are virtually Confucius value; they are part of the traditional values for thousands of years in China.
Gman wrote:
In a way, I blame the communist party there for having such a tight squeeze on the people. But also in another way I also blame the big American companies over there taking advantage of this opportunity to exploit the workers and pay them only $3.45 a day.. To me that is disgraceful.. In other words, it's the people that suffer there.. One group is lording over the people, and the rich Americans are benefiting from it.. How can they voice their opinions about it over there?
Yes I am very sympathetic about them. The Chinese government wants to better their country but everything seems to be hard work. The poorest things are the traditional value - some thoughts instilled in social minds since Confucius 2000 years ago. (you are absolutely right the thousands years of history makes people almost impossible to accept Christian faith. ) Confucism is teaching from a saint in China 2000 years ago; the emperors in Chinese history adopt this sort of social value to instil into the people's mind with education to teach them to absolutely obedient to the elderly and, more importantly, the emperor, without any questioning and doubt. (a blind faith to the government). People who are against this notion is accused of being unethical and risk themselves being ousted by the society at large. I really don't know how they can voice their opinions. Walmart is said to have organised labor union in China, but the problem is the traditional value of Chinese people who don't know that they have the rights to complain at all, and worse still, they don't get accustomed to complain! How pitiful they are! they are educated for thousands of years in their minds: don't complain and be good boys in schools, family, and as a citizens just like getting poisoned in their minds!
The same situation is: no body dares challenge Pharisees and Teacher of the Laws those days amongst Jews because they are educated not to challenge.
Gman wrote:
Anyways, I hope I don't get you in trouble over there over this...
God bless..
I am more than happy to explain more. Fund managers and analysts of investment banks in US, UK and Australia come visiting our firms very often. They are never disillusioned but believe tons of myth about China and I have been having a hard time to explain again and again.
the simplest way to understand China is: imagine a Rambo, finishing his glory in Vietnam war, comes back and grasps power in USA, and being a soldier himself, his policy is: every American has, and is forced, to be a soldier to see the world. How crazy it is!
Oriental.
.