Which one is right
Posted: Sat May 03, 2014 1:28 pm
"The heavens declare the glory of God; the skies proclaim the work of his hands." (Psalm 19:1)
https://discussions.godandscience.org/
The answer is: Jesus
Amen and amen.Jac3510 wrote:All three are wrong, because all three equate eternal security with the final perseverance of the saints.
The correct position is eternal security. NOTHING can cause us to either lose our salvation or prove that we were never saved to begin with. What all three of these articles have in common is this, and it is where they are wrong: all hold that consistent sin/unbelief damns a person to hell, either by arguing that the person was never really saved or by arguing that their sin separated them from their salvation.
Jesus said whoever believes has EVERLASTING life (John 3:16, etc.). If we could die spiritually again once we have been saved then the life that we had at that moment would not have been everlasting. It would have been five month of five year of fifty year life, or whatever the term was from when we were saved to the moment we "died" again. Notice that Jesus does not promise that whoever believes WILL HAVE everlasting life at some point in the future; rather, He says they have it right NOW (John 6:47, etc.).
Christians need to take the Gospel seriously. Our salvation has NOTHING to do with our works, either good or bad. Our good works don't make us one bit more fit for heaven, and our evil works don't edge us one bit closer to hell. I'll say it again and again and again and again: SALVATION IS NOT BY WORKS. When we get that through our thick heads, we'll have made a lot of progress in our spiritual lives.
I often end up doing the wrong thing, the bad thing, the sin...not always what I like to do but end up doing the same. Reminds me constantly of God's grace, and why we need it so bad. I tried fulfilling the commandments and have failed most of the time, in fact to be honest I have failed many many times. I used to carry that burden on me, praying for forgiveness at every second of free time I got, praying for forgiveness on the bus, at lunch break, in between work, study, my daily life was a great confession. If I had a bad thought, I'd pray at the spot for forgiveness, but that did nothing to ease my conscience, the more I err'd the more I prayed and the more I prayed the more guilt and sense of disappointment got into me. The feeling that I was the worst moron God had in his precious hand and you know what it also felt like?Gman wrote:
Right.. Salvation is not by works but we still follow G-d's commandments... Why? Because we are betrothed to G-d. And if we are betrothed to Him we CANNOT act like prostitutes anymore.
I wish I could say I CANNOT. I always end up doing what I don't want to do. Thankfully, our God won't abandon us when we fail. Salvation is by His Grace. And we are secure in HIM. We are not secure in our ability to stop sinning. We are not secure in our ability to follow God's laws. And we are not secure in our own perseverance.Gman wrote:
Right.. Salvation is not by works but we still follow G-d's commandments... Why? Because we are betrothed to G-d. And if we are betrothed to Him we CANNOT act like prostitutes anymore.
What gets me are these three scriptures:Philip wrote:Jac, B.W., so glad you guys weighed in on this - it's absolutely amazing how often the belief that one can lose their salvation comes up. And it both scares, worries and takes away the confidence of so many believers. And it plays right into the devil's hands - as he wants us to doubt our salvation and eternal security. He wants us to pay more attention to our feelings than we do to what God's word tells us about this. And so often, our feelings are all over the map. So, one not feeling as spiritual one week, may worry what that might mean. Alas, WHOSE salvation was it to begin with - certainly not ours - we're, as previously poor beggars, merely the beneficiaries of a magnificent and eternal inheritance, given by grace, through faith!
Seriously? So let me ask you a question.. Let's say you get married to a beautiful wife. But you see she has this habit.. You see she likes to sleep with other men.. So you are telling me that this doesn't matter for the relationship to flourish?neo-x wrote:
I often end up doing the wrong thing, the bad thing, the sin...not always what I like to do but end up doing the same. Reminds me constantly of God's grace, and why we need it so bad. I tried fulfilling the commandments and have failed most of the time, in fact to be honest I have failed many many times. I used to carry that burden on me, praying for forgiveness at every second of free time I got, praying for forgiveness on the bus, at lunch break, in between work, study, my daily life was a great confession. If I had a bad thought, I'd pray at the spot for forgiveness, but that did nothing to ease my conscience, the more I err'd the more I prayed and the more I prayed the more guilt and sense of disappointment got into me. The feeling that I was the worst moron God had in his precious hand and you know what it also felt like?
It felt like "I DON'T DESERVE THIS" because I screw up each time. And God was just on the edge as well, any day now I'd get booted off from his good books, because I just wasn't enough to make the righteous few who didn't behave as sinfully as I did.
My point we do act like sinful whores all the time, may be you don't. But I simply have failed over and over in keeping all of those commandments and I nearly destroyed my faith because of the sense of shame and guilt that failure produced.
Now I trust God, because I know he knows that I am very weak and I need his grace more than he needs me to keep those commandments. Life with sin is a wreck, but life without grace is eternal pain and burden.
I would love to keep his commandments but I don't do a good job of doing so.
I'll but it this way then.. If you are betrothed to Him, sure, you can act anyway you want. But that doesn't sound like a marriage to me unless you are married to vapor.RickD wrote:I wish I could say I CANNOT. I always end up doing what I don't want to do. Thankfully, our God won't abandon us when we fail. Salvation is by His Grace. And we are secure in HIM. We are not secure in our ability to stop sinning. We are not secure in our ability to follow God's laws. And we are not secure in our own perseverance.Gman wrote:
Right.. Salvation is not by works but we still follow G-d's commandments... Why? Because we are betrothed to G-d. And if we are betrothed to Him we CANNOT act like prostitutes anymore.
Correct... Finally someone get's it. Except for the part about following His commandments.. We will still most likely sin in our lives, but we do our best to uphold them and ask forgiveness when we do sin. We follow His commandments BECAUSE we are saved, not to get saved..PaulSacramento wrote:Its not IF we follow the commandments, it is WHY we follow them.
Nothing we do assures us of salvation, especially when we do it with the reason to be saved ( compromised intent).
Our salvation has already been "paid for" by Christ on the cross.
We follow His commandments because we love and honour His sacrifice for us.
We are able to follow those commandments BECAUSE of our faith in Christ and His love and His sacrifice.